3 weeks ago
JD(U) rules out reviewing Bihar's liquor prohibition law
In a place called Bihar, in India, there is a rule that says people cannot sell alcohol.
This rule, called prohibition, was started by a leader named Nitish Kumar.
Some people now want Bihar's leaders to change the rule.
A minister named Jitan Ram Manjhi said the rule is not working well and suggested copying a different way of doing it from the state of Gujarat.
But the JD(U), a political party, said there is no question of changing the rule.
A JD(U) leader named Neeraj Kumar said the rule has helped women who live in villages, and that Prime Minister Narendra Modi appreciated it.
Smart people who study the economy wrote a report about this rule.
They found that the rule makes the government lose a lot of money, and that people are still secretly making and drinking alcohol.
Another leader, Bhai Birendra, agreed that people are still drinking and said the rule should be enforced better.
So some people want to keep the rule, while others think it needs to change.
JD(U) said there is no question of reviewing Bihar's prohibition law, which was implemented during Nitish Kumar's tenure as Chief Minister.
Senior JD(U) leader Neeraj Kumar said the ban brought significant changes in the lives of rural women and was appreciated by PM Modi.
Union Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi urged Chief Minister Samrat Choudhary to implement prohibition on the Gujarat model, citing flaws in the current law.
An NCAER research paper said prohibition causes significant revenue losses and that lifting the ban could boost Bihar's state revenue by 14 to 15 per cent.
RJD leader Bhai Birendra said liquor sales have increased despite the ban, but he remains in favour of prohibition with stronger implementation.
- Who
- JD(U) leaders including MLC Neeraj Kumar, responding to Union Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi; RJD leader Bhai Birendra and the NCAER also weighed in.
- What
- Debate over Bihar's liquor prohibition law, with JD(U) ruling out any review while critics suggest implementing the Gujarat model.
- Where
- Bihar, India, with statements made in Patna
- When
- Tuesday, August 11
- Why
- In response to Jitan Ram Manjhi's call to streamline the prohibition law on the Gujarat model due to flaws in its implementation.
JD(U) — no review of prohibition
Critics — reform the law
Review of the prohibition law
JD(U) — no review of prohibition
JD(U) says there is no question of reviewing the law implemented under Nitish Kumar.
Critics — reform the law
Jitan Ram Manjhi says the law has flaws and should be streamlined on the Gujarat model.
Effectiveness of the ban
JD(U) — no review of prohibition
JD(U) says the ban brought significant changes in rural women's lives and was appreciated by PM Modi.
Critics — reform the law
The NCAER report and RJD leader Bhai Birendra say prohibition has increased bootlegging, liquor sales and corruption, and that enforcement should be strengthened.
Key facts
- State
- Bihar, India
- Law in question
- Bihar's liquor prohibition law
- Law introduced by
- Nitish Kumar (then Chief Minister)
- JD(U) stance
- No question of reviewing the prohibition law
- Manjhi's demand
- Implement prohibition on the Gujarat model
- Estimated revenue impact
- Lifting the ban could boost state revenue by 14-15% (NCAER)
- NCAER findings
- Increase in liquor trade, bootlegging, and consumption of alternative intoxicants
- Report title
- 'Macro perspective of Bihar's development achievements: Unfinished agenda and the way forward'
Quotes
Jitan Ram Manjhi
Union Minister of State, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment
“"There is no question of review of the prohibition law which was implemented during the tenure of our leader Nitish Kumar. I must say that prohibition law has brought significant changes in the lives of rural women."”
theprint.in
“"I would urge Chief Minister Samrat Choudhary to consider implementing the Gujarat model of prohibition in Bihar."”
theprint.in







