1 week ago

Hyderabad Road Sweepers Show Poor Performance Despite ₹40 Crore Spending

Hyderabad Road Sweepers Show Poor Performance Despite ₹40 Crore Spending
Poor Upkeep, Operation of Mechanical Road Sweepers Leaving Roads Dusty · deccanchronicle.com

Hyderabad uses large machines to sweep dust from its roads.

The city spends ₹40 crore every year to operate them.

A study found that the machines removed only about one-third of the road silt on average.

Many machines had worn-out brushes or weak suction.

Some operators reportedly turned off the suction to save fuel.

Six machines even left dust patches behind.

Officials said better maintenance and training could make the machines work properly.

They estimated that effective sweeping could improve air quality by 15% to 20%.

Payments may be linked to proof that the machines are working effectively.

Key facts

Annual spending
₹40 crore is paid to contractors each year to operate the mechanical road sweepers.
Machines studied
40 mechanical road sweepers were assessed at 40 Hyderabad locations.
Average efficiency
Average silt-removal efficiency was 32.7%.
Low-performing locations
17 locations recorded efficiency below 25%, while 28 recorded efficiency below 50%.
High-performing locations
Only two locations recorded efficiency above 75%.
Maintenance problems
Brush and suction conditions received the lowest ratings for 95% of the machines surveyed.
Potential air-quality benefit
Officials said properly functioning sweepers could improve Hyderabad’s ambient air quality by 15% to 20%.

Quotes

A Telangana Pollution Control Board source

An unnamed source from the Telangana Pollution Control Board discussing mechanical sweeper performance

“It is not uncommon to see ‘lofting’ of dust when a MRS machine is at work. This shows there is either no suction or not enough suction. There were also several doubts whether the machines were actually working or just being driven around as the contractors are paid using a GPS tagging mechanism.”
deccanchronicle.com
“With `40 crore being spent a year on these machines, the presumption is that they work efficiently. The present system is not performance linked.”
deccanchronicle.com

Sources

Related news