9 hrs ago
Maduro Invokes Head-of-State Immunity in U.S. Drug Case
Nicolas Maduro is asking a U.S. judge to throw out criminal charges against him.
He says leaders of countries should usually be protected from prosecution in other countries.
The United States says it has not recognized him as Venezuela’s president since 2019.
U.S. courts have rarely handled criminal cases involving foreign leaders.
A similar immunity argument by Manuel Noriega was rejected in 1990.
Maduro has pleaded not guilty.
The judge will hear arguments about his request on November 17.
If the case continues, the trial is scheduled to begin on June 1, 2027.
Ousted Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro asked a U.S. judge to dismiss drug-trafficking charges.
Maduro argues that sitting heads of state are protected from prosecution abroad under international law.
The United States has not recognized Maduro as Venezuela’s president since 2019.
Maduro’s charges formed the basis of a January 3 U.S. military operation that captured him in Caracas.
If his motion fails, Maduro is scheduled to stand trial on June 1, 2027.
- Who
- Ousted Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro and U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein.
- What
- Maduro is seeking dismissal of U.S. drug-trafficking charges by claiming head-of-state immunity.
- Where
- The case is in Manhattan federal court in New York; the related operation took place in Caracas.
- When
- The motion was reported on September 2; prosecutors must respond by October 2, and a hearing is scheduled for November 17.
- Why
- Maduro argues that international law protects sitting heads of state from prosecution abroad, while the United States does not recognize him as Venezuela’s president.
Maduro’s Position
U.S. Position
Head-of-state immunity
Maduro’s Position
Maduro argues that, as the head of a sovereign country, he should be immune from prosecution in a foreign court.
U.S. Position
The United States has not recognized Maduro as Venezuela’s president since 2019, and U.S. courts generally defer to the president and cabinet on recognition of foreign leaders.
Legitimacy of Venezuela’s elections
Maduro’s Position
Maduro says Venezuela’s 2018 and 2024 elections were fair and has accused Washington of seeking to remove him to gain control of Venezuela’s oil wealth.
U.S. Position
The United States said the 2018 election was rigged and called Maduro’s 2024 reelection fraudulent.
Likely legal outcome
Maduro’s Position
Maduro is seeking dismissal of the indictment before trial.
U.S. Position
Legal experts cited by Reuters said he faces an uphill battle, noting that similar immunity claims have generally not succeeded in comparable U.S. cases.
Key facts
- Defendant
- Nicolas Maduro, ousted president of Venezuela
- Charges
- Criminal drug-trafficking charges
- Judge
- U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein
- Plea
- Maduro has pleaded not guilty
- Response deadline
- U.S. prosecutors must respond by October 2
- Dismissal hearing
- November 17
- Potential trial date
- June 1, 2027
Sources
Related news
Maduro’s Immunity Bid Tests U.S. Courts and International Law
Maduro Shares Jail Photos, Says He Is Standing Firm
US Sanctions ICC President, Senior Lawyer, Vows Wider Campaign
Nicolás Maduro Shares Prison Photos, Sends Message of Hope
Honduran Court Drops Charges Against Pardoned Former President Hernandez
US Sanctions ICC President in Latest Trump Escalation
Who Is Alejandro Betancourt, Trump’s Proposed Venezuelan Oil Partner?
US Firms Sign Historic Multibillion-Dollar Venezuelan Oil Deals
Trump Claims Historic Venezuelan Oil Deal Amid Major Uncertainties
Venezuela reports 6,438 deaths from June twin earthquakes
