1 hr ago
Plea Challenges Appointment of Election Chief and Commissioners
A person has asked the Supreme Court to review how three election officials were appointed.
The person says the appointment process did not follow a law passed in 2023.
That law, according to the petition, called for five possible candidates for each open job.
There were two openings, but the committee reportedly recommended only six names.
The petition also says a list of more than 200 people went to the opposition leader before the committee finished its shortlist.
The Supreme Court had earlier said the law appeared to call for ten candidates for two openings.
The petition challenges the appointments of Gyanesh Kumar, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, and Vivek Joshi.
A Supreme Court petition challenges the appointments of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.
Petitioner Suri Payala alleges the appointments breached the process set out in the 2023 appointments law.
The petition says the Search Committee proposed six names for two vacancies in March 2024, rather than five names for each vacancy.
A March 22, 2024 Supreme Court order said the law appeared to require ten prospective candidates for two vacant posts.
The plea says a list of more than 200 people was sent to the Leader of the Opposition before the Search Committee finalized its shortlist; the next day, six names were recommended and Kumar and Sandhu were selected.
- Who
- Petitioner Suri Payala challenges the appointments of Gyanesh Kumar, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, and Vivek Joshi.
- What
- A plea alleges that the appointments violated the procedure in the 2023 law.
- Where
- Supreme Court of India.
- When
- The vacancies arose in March 2024; the Supreme Court order cited in the plea was dated March 22, 2024.
- Why
- The plea says the Search Committee recommended six names for two vacancies, rather than five names per vacancy as required by the law.
Petitioner's allegation
Appointment process
Number of candidates shortlisted
Petitioner's allegation
The petitioner says the law required five prospective candidates for each vacancy, meaning ten for two vacancies, but only six names were recommended.
Appointment process
The article reports that the Search Committee recommended six names and that Kumar and Sandhu were selected; it does not provide a response from the officials or government defending the process.
Timing of candidate list
Petitioner's allegation
The plea says a list of more than 200 people was sent to the Leader of the Opposition before the Search Committee finalized its shortlist.
Appointment process
The article does not include a response to this allegation from the government or the officials involved.
Key facts
- Petitioner
- Suri Payala
- Appointees named
- Gyanesh Kumar, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, and Vivek Joshi
- Law cited
- Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- Vacancies
- Two Election Commissioner vacancies arose in March 2024
- Names proposed
- The petition says the Search Committee recommended six names for the two vacancies
- Supreme Court order
- On March 22, 2024, the Court said the law appeared to call for ten prospective candidates for two vacant posts
- Earlier list
- The plea says more than 200 names were sent to the Leader of the Opposition before the shortlist was finalized
Quotes
Supreme Court
The court, in its March 22, 2024 order on the 2023 appointments law.
“Section 6 “postulates five prospective candidates which appears to mean that for two vacant posts ten prospective candidates should have been shortlisted”.”
indianexpress.com
Sources
Related news
Supreme Court to Hear Challenge to CEC’s ECI Functioning
Supreme Court to Hear Pleas Challenging CEC’s Unilateral Decisions
Supreme Court Split Over Election Commissioner Appointment Law Reference
Supreme Court to Hear Pleas Seeking CEC Kumar’s Suspension
Supreme Court to Consider Recall of Election Appointments Verdict
Supreme Court Seeks Replies, Declines to Suspend Election Chief
Konda Surekha Calls for Stronger Voting Rights Safeguards
Rahul Gandhi Leads Opposition Protest Over Voter Rights
Jagga Reddy and Nirmala Continue Rahul Gandhi Solidarity Protest
INDIA Bloc Weighs Further Protests Over Alleged Vote Chori
