3 weeks ago

Can Indian Knowledge Systems Be Defended From Pseudoscience?

Can Indian Knowledge Systems Be Defended From Pseudoscience?
Can the Indian Knowledge Systems be defended from pseudoscience? · scroll.in

A professor who studies the history of mathematics in India wrote about a big problem.

Some people mix up real science with ideas that cannot be tested, like magic.

Real science lets you try to prove it wrong, and if a test fails, the idea is corrected or thrown away.

The professor says some Indian institutes are putting untestable ideas like 'energy chakras' and 'the science of reincarnation' next to real science at big conferences.

At one conference in IIT Mandi, scientists talked about brain machines and meditation, but also about rebirth and astrology.

A speaker at IIT Madras said a sound made by NASA from the Big Bang proves the universe said 'Om,' which is not what science shows.

Scientists at IIT Roorkee said cow urine can stop a virus, and a science journal is now checking that claim.

The professor thinks this confuses students and the public, who trust big institutions.

He says the amazing mathematics of old India, like Ramanujan's work, is wonderful on its own and does not need made-up claims.

Key facts

Author
Aalok Thakkar, Assistant Professor of Computer Science, Ashoka University
Event
3rd Mind, Brain and Consciousness Conference (MBCC 2026), June 2026
Host institution
IIT Mandi's Indian Knowledge System and Mental Health Applications Centre
Patronage
Indian Knowledge Systems Division, Ministry of Education
Conference scale
19 keynote lectures, 250 technical presentations, 275-page abstract book
'Quantum Emotion' session
3 hours, 14 papers
SUTRA-PIC funding
Nearly Rs 98 crore for research on cow-derived products
Cow urine study
Claimed antiviral activity against chikungunya; journal investigation opened

Quotes

Director, IIT Mandi

Director of IIT Mandi

“Delighted to share that the home‑grown flagship conference of the IKSMHA Centre at @iit__mandi, the 3rd Mind Brain Consciousness Conference (MBCC 2026), is set to bring together leading minds exploring consciousness, neuroscience, cognition, meditation, philosophy, and Indian…”
scroll.in

Sources

Related news