2 weeks ago
Allahabad High Court Flags Huge Disparity in Private Hospital Fees
A court in India called the Allahabad High Court said that some private hospitals charge sick people very high and very different prices for the same treatments.
The judges said patients should not be made to pay unfair, huge bills just because they are ill.
The court is worried that there are not strong enough rules to keep hospital prices fair.
There is a law from 2010 that was supposed to set good standards for hospitals, but the judges say it does not do enough to make sure prices are reasonable.
Hospitals are supposed to show their prices and charge within a set range, but that does not seem to always happen.
The court asked the government for a list of private hospitals that got government help, like cheap land.
Those hospitals were supposed to give cheaper treatment to poor people.
The court also wants to know if the councils that watch over hospitals are actually working.
It asked for reports about hospital inspections in Lucknow from the last five years.
The state government must explain what it is doing, and the next court hearing will be on September 21.
The Allahabad High Court flagged a 'huge disparity' in private hospital fees and said patients should not be 'fleeced' with exorbitant bills merely because they are ill.
A Lucknow bench of Justices Rajan Roy and Manjive Shukla passed the order on a public interest litigation filed by local NGO We The People.
The court noted the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010 lacks an adequate mechanism to ensure uniformity or rationality in medical treatment charges.
The court sought district-wise details of private hospitals established with government assistance, including subsidised land, and questioned whether national and state councils of clinical establishments are functional.
Authorities were asked for inspection details and the state government was directed to file a supplementary affidavit; the next hearing is on September 21.
- Who
- The Allahabad High Court, through its Lucknow bench comprising Justices Rajan Roy and Manjive Shukla
- What
- Raised concerns over the 'huge disparity' in private hospital fees and the lack of regulation of medical treatment charges
- Where
- Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh
- When
- The order was passed on August 6, with the next hearing scheduled for September 21
- Why
- To ensure sick patients are not 'fleeced' with exorbitant bills and to check whether existing laws and councils adequately regulate private hospital charges
Key facts
- Court
- Allahabad High Court (Lucknow bench)
- Judges
- Justices Rajan Roy and Manjive Shukla
- Petitioner
- NGO We The People
- Order Date
- August 6
- Next Hearing
- September 21
- Key Law Cited
- Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010
- Rules Cited
- Rule 9, Clinical Establishments (Central Government) Rules, 2012
- State Concerned
- Uttar Pradesh









