3 weeks ago
Columnist Argues Politics, Not Sanatan Dharma, Is the Problem
A writer named Gitanjali wrote an article about Sanatan Dharma, a very old and important way of thinking from India.
Some people were upset when she said a big student protest showed people acting with kindness and fairness, which she called Sanatan Dharma in action.
They called her unkind names on the internet, and she wanted to explain what she really meant.
She says Sanatan Dharma is about being truthful, fair, patient, listening to other people's ideas, and caring about everyone, not just your own group.
She thinks the real problem is not Sanatan Dharma itself, but the way politicians have used it.
She remembers that in 2014 many Indians voted for the BJP party because they wanted India to feel proud of its own culture again.
But she says calling people who ask questions 'anti-national' does not match the old teachings, which were full of questions and debates.
She also worries that movies sometimes show Muslim characters as bad guys, which is not fair to real people.
She hopes the government will treat everyone the same, no matter what religion they follow.
In the end, she says that being truly good is bigger than any political party, and Sanatan Dharma will survive even without the BJP.
Columnist Gitanjali J Angmo, founder of the Himalayan Institute of Alternatives in Ladakh, argues the problem is not Sanatan Dharma but what politics has done to it.
Her earlier piece describing the Sansad Chalo protest as 'Sanatan Dharma in action' drew backlash, with critics labelling her a 'Sanghi', 'BJP stooge' and 'RSS sympathiser'.
She says the BJP understood Indians' longing to look inward again and presented itself as the custodian of India's Hindu inheritance.
She criticises intolerance, such as labelling government questioners 'anti-national' or 'Chinese agents', and says Hindu texts like the Bhagavad Gita are built on questioning and dialogue.
She questions religion-based personal laws and state management of temples, urges debate on a Uniform Civil Code, and says Sanatan Dharma does not need the BJP to survive.
- Who
- Gitanjali J Angmo, founder of the Himalayan Institute of Alternatives in Ladakh, writing about the BJP and current Indian political discourse.
- What
- An opinion column arguing that the problem is not Sanatan Dharma itself but what politics has done to it, and challenging the BJP to live up to the tradition it claims to defend.
- Where
- India, with the author based in Ladakh.
- When
- Not explicitly stated; the piece refers to the 'last 12 years' of Indian politics since the 2014 general election.
- Why
- Written in response to backlash — labels such as 'Sanghi', 'BJP stooge' and 'RSS sympathiser' — after she described the Sansad Chalo protest as 'Sanatan Dharma in action'.
Sanatan Dharma as a living tradition
Sanatan Dharma as political identity
What Sanatan Dharma means
Sanatan Dharma as a living tradition
The author argues Sanatan Dharma is a discipline of living centred on truth, justice, patience, understanding opponents and the welfare of all — not an identity to be defended against another.
Sanatan Dharma as political identity
The online reaction treated any invocation of Sanatan Dharma as placing the speaker on one side of India's political divide, labelling the writer a 'Sanghi', 'BJP stooge' and 'RSS sympathiser'.
Questioning the government
Sanatan Dharma as a living tradition
A living society questions and a confident government answers; Hindu texts like the Bhagavad Gita are built on dialogue and debate.
Sanatan Dharma as political identity
Current political practice labels those who question the government as anti-national, foreign-funded or 'Chinese agents', a response the author says shrinks rather than flowers the tradition.
Key facts
- Author
- Gitanjali J Angmo
- Author's role
- Founder, Himalayan Institute of Alternatives, Ladakh
- Main argument
- The problem is not Sanatan Dharma but what politics has done to it
- Trigger
- Backlash to her column calling the Sansad Chalo protest 'Sanatan Dharma in action'
- Labels received
- Sanghi, BJP stooge, RSS sympathiser
- Film criticised
- Dhurandhar, for placing Muslim and Pakistani characters in a silhouette of villainy
- Key quote
- Sri Aurobindo: 'When it is said that India shall rise, it is the Sanatan Dharma that shall rise.'
- Policy question raised
- A Uniform Civil Code and equality before the law regardless of religion
Quotes
Gitanjali J Angmo
Author and founder of Himalayan Institute of Alternatives, Ladakh
“The real problem is not Sanatan Dharma itself but what politics has done to it.”
indianexpress.com









