4 days ago
SYL Canal Deadlock Pits Punjab Water Fears Against Haryana Claims
The Satluj-Yamuna Link, or SYL, is a canal meant to carry water from Punjab to Haryana.
Haryana says it should receive water because of an agreement made in 1981 and several court decisions.
Punjab says it does not have extra water and that its own farmers and villages are already facing shortages.
Many parts of Punjab are using groundwater faster than it can be replaced.
Haryana also says some of its districts have serious water problems.
The canal is unfinished because Punjab has not completed its section.
A tribunal is checking how much Ravi-Beas water is actually available today.
The two states may still need to find a political solution, even after the tribunal reports.
Punjab and Haryana have shown cordiality during a recent Supreme Court hearing, but a substantive breakthrough remains uncertain.
Punjab opposes transferring water, citing groundwater depletion, canal shortages and its riparian-rights argument.
Haryana says it is entitled to Ravi-Beas waters under the 1981 agreement and successive Supreme Court rulings.
The 214-kilometre SYL canal includes 122 kilometres in Punjab and 92 kilometres in Haryana; Haryana has completed its section.
A Ravi-Beas Waters Tribunal is assessing whether the water assumed available under the 1981 agreement still exists.
- Who
- The governments of Punjab and Haryana, with the Supreme Court of India and the Ravi-Beas Waters Tribunal involved.
- What
- A long-running dispute over completing the Satluj-Yamuna Link canal and distributing Ravi-Beas waters.
- Where
- The proposed 214-kilometre canal runs through Punjab and Haryana; the tribunal also inspected Ravi-Beas water sites in Punjab.
- When
- The dispute has continued for about 30 years; a recent Supreme Court hearing took place months before Punjab Assembly elections expected early next year.
- Why
- Punjab says it faces severe groundwater depletion and lacks surplus water, while Haryana seeks its claimed share under the 1981 agreement and court rulings.
Punjab's Position
Haryana's Position
Water availability
Punjab's Position
Punjab says it has severe groundwater depletion, shortages of canal water and no surplus water to provide to Haryana or Rajasthan.
Haryana's Position
Haryana says it faces water stress in southern and south-western districts and should receive its share of Ravi-Beas waters.
Legal basis
Punjab's Position
Punjab invokes the riparian principle and challenges the 1981 tripartite agreement, arguing that only Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir are within the Ravi-Beas basin.
Haryana's Position
Haryana relies on its status as a successor state of undivided Punjab, the 1981 agreement and successive Supreme Court rulings directing Punjab to complete its section.
Canal completion
Punjab's Position
The return of land acquired for the canal and strong local opposition create major practical and political obstacles to construction in Punjab.
Haryana's Position
Haryana has completed its section and continues to press Punjab to finish the remaining stretch, including through a Rs 100 crore allocation.
Key facts
- Canal length
- The SYL was designed as a 214-kilometre link.
- State sections
- Punjab's section is 122 kilometres, while Haryana's is 92 kilometres.
- Haryana's progress
- Haryana has completed its portion of the canal.
- 1981 water assessment
- The agreement allocated Ravi-Beas waters assessed at 17.17 million acre feet.
- Punjab groundwater
- The article says roughly 73–76% of Punjab's blocks are overexploited.
- Haryana funding
- Haryana earmarked Rs 100 crore for the canal this year.
- Tribunal
- The Ravi-Beas Waters Tribunal is headed by retired Supreme Court judge Justice Vineet Saran.
Quotes
Nayab Singh Saini
Haryana chief minister advocating that Punjab share water with Haryana
“Paani chhado, tibka nahin dinde (forget about water, we won’t give a drop)”
indianexpress.com
“We are one. I appeal to our elder brother to share water with us.”
indianexpress.com
Sources
Related news
Punjab, Haryana near resolution of decades-old SYL dispute
Centre tells Supreme Court Punjab close to BBMB dues settlement
India Rejects Hague Ruling Upholding Pakistan Water Treaty
Hague Court Says India Must Uphold Indus Waters Treaty
India’s River-Linking Ambitions Face Engineering and Ecological Challenges
Biomedical Waste Found Outside Bhopal Hospital; Supervisors Dismissed
US-Made Xi Experience Centre Arrives for Bhopal Robotic Surgery Training
Bhopal Police Assign Four Cyber Officers To Speed Fraud Refunds
CSIR-IICT and ReSL Sign Pact for Sustainability Research
