1 month ago
Indian Carmakers Split Over CAFE 2 Credit System
The Indian government wants to change the rules for carmakers to meet fuel-efficiency targets.
Some carmakers, like Tata Motors and JSW MG Motor, don't like the changes because they think it's unfair to change the rules so late.
Other carmakers, like Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai, support the changes because they think it's a fair way to comply with the rules.
The disagreement might delay the finalization of these rules.
The Indian government proposed a credit-debit system for carmakers to meet CAFE 2 fuel-efficiency targets.
Tata Motors and JSW MG Motor oppose the retrospective application of the system.
Other carmakers like Maruti Suzuki, Hyundai, and Mahindra support the system.
The disagreement could delay the finalization of the CAFE 2 rules.
The credit-debit system allows carmakers to buy credits to offset excess emissions.
- Who
- Indian carmakers including Tata Motors, JSW MG Motor, Maruti Suzuki, Hyundai, and Mahindra.
- What
- Disagreement over the introduction of a credit-debit system for CAFE 2 norms.
- Where
- New Delhi, India.
- When
- The disagreement surfaced during a meeting of the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (Siam) on Friday.
- Why
- Tata Motors and JSW MG Motor oppose the retrospective application of the credit-debit system, while other carmakers support it.
Opposition to Retrospective Changes
Support for Credit System
Retrospective Application
Opposition to Retrospective Changes
Tata Motors and JSW MG Motor oppose the retrospective application of the credit-debit system for CAFE 2, arguing it changes rules unfairly late in the game.
Support for Credit System
Other carmakers like Maruti Suzuki, Hyundai, and Mahindra support the system, seeing it as a fair way to comply with regulations.
Credit Purchase from Regulator
Opposition to Retrospective Changes
Tata Motors argues that buying credits directly from the regulator without corresponding emission improvements is merely an accounting measure.
Support for Credit System
Supporters view the credit system as a necessary mechanism to avoid stiff penalties and ensure compliance.
Key facts
- CAFE 2
- Corporate Average Fuel Efficiency norms introduced in 2022.
- CAFE 3
- Next iteration of CAFE norms scheduled to start in April 2027.
- Credit-Debit System
- Allows carmakers to buy credits to offset excess emissions.
- Penalty for Non-Compliance
- ₹5,000 per g CO₂/km.
- Credit Purchase Rate
- ₹2,500 per g CO₂/km from the regulator.
Quotes
Tata Motors','letter
Tata Motors' letter to the Union power secretary
“We are united on the introduction of this system in CAFE 3, which will start from next year. But the opposition of this system for CAFE 2 has created a consensus problem now. Most of the carmakers who were part of the meeting are okay with this system for CAFE 2 going ahead, but the new opposition will lead to further discussions on this issue.”
livemint.com
“If Credits can be created by BEE merely against payment, without any corresponding improvement emission, such Credits would not have the same character. They would effectively be accounting entries used to extinguish Debits arising as a result of noncompliance.”
livemint.com
Sources
Related news
UK and Ukraine Open Battlefield AI Partnership Amid War
Volvo ES90 And EX90 Electric Flagships Launch In India
Parvez, Bhuvaneshwari Lead A2H Children’s Chess Tournament Winners
Ten Kautilya Students Secure Top Management Admissions Through IPMAT
Explorica Students Earn Top Cambridge Checkpoint Rankings
Four 2026 Scholarships Offer Support Across Education Levels
India Passenger Vehicle Dispatches Reach Record August High
Why JSW MG Motor May Bring EREV Technology to India
Parth Jindal Named Chairman as JSW MG Pursues Expansion
MG Hector Tomahawk PHEV Challenges Toyota Hybrid Pricing
Gujarat Plans VGGS 2027 Investor Outreach in New Delhi
