1 week ago
Madras High Court Quashes Case Over Pastor Dancing Tweet
A man posted a video on Twitter showing a foreign pastor dancing with a woman.
He added a message asking Hindus to think about the religious culture shown in the video.
A Christian man complained that the post was offensive.
The government said the post might cause trouble between religious groups.
The man’s lawyer said the video was not a deepfake and had no obscene caption.
The Madras High Court examined the case.
The judge said the message was directed at Hindus, not Christians.
The court therefore ended the criminal case and called continuing it an abuse of the law.
The Madras High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a Tamil Nadu Hindu rights organisation president.
The case concerned a June 18, 2023, Twitter post showing a foreign pastor dancing with a woman.
The accompanying caption said the video depicted foreign religious culture and urged Hindus to think it over.
The complainant, who belongs to the Christian community, said the caption was offensive and filed a police complaint.
The court found the prosecution’s continuation to be an abuse of the legal process, while the government argued the post could create religious enmity.
- Who
- The president of a Tamil Nadu-based Hindu rights organisation was prosecuted after a complaint by a Christian community member; Justice R Vijayakumar heard the case.
- What
- The Madras High Court quashed criminal proceedings over a Twitter video and accompanying caption concerning foreign religious culture.
- Where
- The video was posted on Twitter; the case was decided by the Madras High Court.
- When
- The video was posted on June 18, 2023; the court’s order was dated August 24.
- Why
- The complainant considered the caption offensive, while the government argued that the post could create enmity between religious groups; the court found continuation of the case an abuse of process.
Petitioner’s and Court’s View
Government’s View
Meaning of the caption
Petitioner’s and Court’s View
The petitioner argued that the caption addressed Hindus rather than Christians, and the court accepted that distinction.
Government’s View
The government argued that the video and caption together were likely to create enmity between different religious groups.
Nature of the video
Petitioner’s and Court’s View
The petitioner’s lawyer said the video was original, not a deepfake, and was posted without an obscene caption.
Government’s View
The government focused on the repeated posting of similar videos and the potential effect of this post, rather than accepting the petitioner’s characterization.
Continuation of the case
Petitioner’s and Court’s View
The court held that continuing the criminal proceedings was an abuse of the process of law and quashed the charge sheet.
Government’s View
The government opposed the petition, maintaining that the post warranted criminal proceedings because of its possible communal impact.
Key facts
- Court
- Madras High Court
- Judge
- Justice R Vijayakumar
- Video posting date
- June 18, 2023, at around 5 p.m.
- Platform
- Complainant
- A member of the Christian community
- Government position
- The post was likely to create enmity between different religious groups
- Outcome
- Criminal proceedings and the charge sheet were quashed
Quotes
Justice R Vijayakumar
Madras High Court judge who issued the order quashing the proceedings
“As far as the caption is concerned, the petitioner has stated that the said video depicts the original state of foreign culture and therefore, Hindus should think it over. The alleged caption is not meant for the Christians. It is addressed to the Hindus.”
indianexpress.com
Sources
Related news
Kerala Anchor Faces Police Case After Debate Over Muslim Scholar
Delhi High Court Seeks Review of Sai Baba Videos
Delhi Police seek Google details in Dhruv Rathee video probe
Tipu Sultan Cutout Video Prompts FIR in Chikkamagaluru
Delhi High Court Stays Defamation Case Against Sudarshan TV
Satheesan’s Facebook Post Criticising Islamic Scholar Disappears, CMO Cites Glitch
George Clooney Wins Golden Lion, Questions Paramount-Warner Bros Merger
Former Twitter Staffer Launches Twitter.now Against Elon Musk’s X
Late-Night DM Helped JEE Aspirant Reach ₹1 Crore by 22
Divine revives Vine’s six-second loops with open social platform
