1 week ago
IRCTC Sues Influencer Over Rail Neer Bromate Claim
An influencer said a bottle of Rail Neer water had too much bromate in it.
Bromate is a chemical that can form when water is disinfected.
The influencer said testing found 0.084 milligrams per litre.
The limit mentioned in the report was 0.01 milligrams per litre.
IRCTC disagreed with the broader concerns and said it follows safety rules.
It said its factories regularly test the water for chemical and biological safety.
IRCTC has started legal action against the influencer.
More independent testing may help determine what happened with that particular sample.
Trustified claimed a Rail Neer sample contained bromate at 0.084 mg per litre.
The reported level was 8.4 times the cited limit of 0.01 mg per litre.
IRCTC initiated legal action through its legal department and appointed a lawyer.
IRCTC said Rail Neer follows BIS and FSSAI quality requirements.
The dispute centers on whether the reported sample result can be independently verified.
- Who
- The Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation and the Trustified YouTube channel are involved.
- What
- IRCTC initiated legal action after Trustified claimed a Rail Neer sample exceeded the prescribed bromate limit.
- Where
- The report is datelined Mumbai and concerns Rail Neer sold at railway stations and on trains.
- When
- The article does not specify when the legal action or laboratory test occurred.
- Why
- IRCTC said its quality-control systems comply with applicable standards, while the influencer’s claim raised questions about a particular sample’s safety.
Influencer’s Laboratory Claim
IRCTC’s Quality Assurance Response
Bromate level
Influencer’s Laboratory Claim
Trustified said laboratory testing found 0.084 mg per litre of bromate in a Rail Neer sample, about 8.4 times the cited limit.
IRCTC’s Quality Assurance Response
IRCTC said Rail Neer is manufactured in compliance with applicable standards and undergoes prescribed quality checks.
Scope of the finding
Influencer’s Laboratory Claim
The reported test prompted questions about the safety of packaged water supplied to railway passengers.
IRCTC’s Quality Assurance Response
The result concerns a particular sample and does not establish that all Rail Neer contains bromate above the prescribed limit.
Verification
Influencer’s Laboratory Claim
The laboratory report was cited as the basis for the claim.
IRCTC’s Quality Assurance Response
The key unresolved issue is whether the result can be independently verified and reconciled with IRCTC’s own testing.
Key facts
- Product
- Rail Neer packaged drinking water
- Reported bromate level
- 0.084 mg per litre, or 84 micrograms per litre
- Cited prescribed limit
- 0.01 mg per litre, or 10 micrograms per litre
- Claim source
- Trustified YouTube channel
- IRCTC response
- Legal action was initiated through IRCTC’s legal department, with a lawyer appointed.
- Quality standards
- IRCTC said testing follows applicable Bureau of Indian Standards and Food Safety and Standards Authority of India regulations.
- Outstanding issue
- Whether the reported result can be independently verified and reconciled with IRCTC’s testing.
Sources
Related news
IRCTC seizes unapproved water and food in nationwide train inspections
Indian Railways Plans Major Water Safety Overhaul Across Stations
Railways Orders Immediate Action on Drinking Water After CAG Report
Railways order filtration at 20,000 locations after E. coli report
Railways Order Safe Drinking Water Drive After CAG Report
Railways Launch 10-Day Water Cooler Inspection Drive After CAG Findings
Western Railway Extends 24 Special Trains Across 12 Routes
IRCTC’s 11-Day Northeast Tour Covers Three States For ₹50,000
Delhi court delays charges in Lalu land-for-job cases
Railways Plans Special Trains Amid Durga Puja Demand
Mumbai–Subedarganj Amrit Bharat Express Gets Weekly Service
