11 hrs ago
Judge Weighs News Outlets’ Bid to Keep White House Ban Blocked
CNN, MS NOW and Politico want their journalists to keep access to the White House.
President Trump’s administration had revoked their press passes.
The outlets say this was punishment for their reporting.
The Justice Department says the outlets published classified and false information and argues the ban is justified.
A judge temporarily stopped the ban in September, saying the outlets likely were not treated fairly.
At the October 8 hearing, the outlets also argued the ban limited free speech.
The judge had not yet decided that claim.
He said he would rule by Tuesday, when the temporary order was due to expire.
CNN, MS NOW and Politico asked a federal judge to keep their journalists protected from a White House access ban.
The outlets say President Donald Trump’s revocation of their press passes was retaliation for their coverage.
The Justice Department argues the ban is justified, alleging the outlets published classified and false information.
Judge Timothy Kelly temporarily blocked the ban on September 24, finding it likely violated Fifth Amendment due-process protections.
At an October 8 hearing, the outlets also argued the ban violated free-speech protections; Kelly said he would rule by Tuesday.
- Who
- CNN, MS NOW and Politico are seeking continued protection; the case is before U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly.
- What
- The outlets asked the judge to keep blocking the White House press-access ban while their lawsuit proceeds.
- Where
- Washington, D.C.
- When
- The hearing was held October 8; the temporary block was due to expire Tuesday.
- Why
- The outlets call the pass revocations retaliation for their coverage; the Justice Department cites national security concerns over stories it says disclosed classified information.
News organizations
Trump administration
Reason for revoking access
News organizations
CNN, MS NOW and Politico say revoking their passes was unlawful retaliation for their coverage and that the national security rationale is meritless.
Trump administration
The Justice Department says the outlets published classified and false information, endangered national security, and failed to meet standards of journalistic professionalism.
Effect on press freedom
News organizations
The outlets argue the ban violates First Amendment protections and could discourage reporting that reflects poorly on Trump.
Trump administration
The Justice Department maintains that the ban is legally justified on national security grounds.
Key facts
- News organizations
- CNN, MS NOW and Politico
- Judge
- U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly
- Temporary block
- Issued September 24; due to expire Tuesday
- Constitutional ruling so far
- Kelly found the ban likely violated Fifth Amendment due-process protections
- Claim still at issue
- The outlets’ claim that the ban violates First Amendment free-speech protections
- Government’s stated rationale
- National security concerns tied to alleged publication of classified information
- Stories cited by the Justice Department
- Reporting on construction of Trump’s White House ballroom and turnout at a Republican midterm convention
- Requested relief
- An order blocking the ban while the lawsuit continues
Quotes
Theodore Boutrous
Attorney for CNN, MS NOW and Politico
“Here we have the unusual situation where the president himself has said he wants to chill speech. He wants to coerce better coverage.”
theprint.in
“shouldn’t be able to constantly write or report FICTION and LIES when they’re covering the President of the United States.”
theprint.in
Sources
Related news
Judge Orders Temporary Restoration of Trump Press Access
CNN, MS NOW and Politico Regain White House Access
Judge Extends Temporary Lift on White House Media Ban
Trump Ban Blocks CNN, MS NOW, Politico From White House
Trump's White House Media Ban Faces Legal Challenge
Trump Ban Denies CNN, MS NOW, Politico White House Access
Media Outlets Fight Trump White House Ban in Court
CNN Enters Skydance Era as Editorial Independence Faces Scrutiny
DOJ Defends White House Restrictions on CNN, MS NOW, Politico
