Health · Healthcare & Policy · 3 hrs ago
Opinion: Restrictive training may foster learned helplessness in doctors
Former surgeon Frances Mei Hardin says some residents face restrictive rules in clinical settings.
She describes trainees who must ask permission to eat, drink or use the restroom.
Many are in their 30s and have medical or other graduate degrees.
Hardin argues that infantilizing treatment can foster learned helplessness, when people stop trying to change a situation because they believe they lack control.
Residents’ responsibility for patients grows quickly during training, she says.
The concern is that trainees may feel powerless even when they could act, affecting how they respond to difficult conditions.
Hardin’s column introduces a series about challenges facing people who practice medicine during a time of change.
STAT published an opinion column arguing that restrictive treatment of resident physicians can foster learned helplessness.
The column says some residents must ask permission to use the restroom or take time to eat or drink.
It argues that this treatment can be infantilizing even as residents take on growing responsibility for patients’ lives.
Learned helplessness is described as stopping efforts to change an unfavorable situation because a person believes they cannot affect the outcome.
The column was written by Frances Mei Hardin, a former ear, nose, and throat surgeon.
- Who
- Resident physicians, and columnist Frances Mei Hardin.
- What
- Hardin argues that restrictive and infantilizing training can foster learned helplessness in doctors.
- When
- STAT published the column on October 13, 2026.
- Where
- Some clinical settings; the article does not identify specific locations.
- Why
- Hardin says residents may come to believe they have no control over unfavorable situations.
This story does not have two clearly opposing sides.
This story does not have a timeline yet.
- Publication date
- October 13, 2026
- Author
- Frances Mei Hardin
- Column
- Chief Complaint
- Examples of restricted tasks
- Eating, drinking, or using the restroom
- Residents' age
- Many are approaching or in their 30s
What people are saying
a psychological state wherein a person stops trying to change an unfavorable or unsavory situation because they believe that they have no control over the outcome, even when they do.








