Politics · Indonesia · 1 hr ago
Former KPU chief says disputed election rule was discussed and approved
Former Indonesian election commission chief Hasyim Asy'ari says a disputed clause in the rules for presidential candidates was discussed at a parliamentary meeting in September 2023.
He was responding to Ahmad Doli Kurnia, who had said the clause was not discussed by the commission and parliament.
Hasyim says the commission sent parliament a draft regulation before the meeting, and the clause was included in the draft.
He says Doli, then head of parliament's Commission II, attended and signed the meeting's conclusions, along with other officials.
Hasyim rejects claims that the clause was secretly inserted or manipulated.
The dispute concerns a clause in the rules for the 2024 presidential election, and Hasyim says responsibility for it is shared by those who took part in the meeting.
He also urged the ethics council examining a complaint about the clause to act fairly, noting that the council had participated in the meeting and signed its conclusions.
Former Indonesian Election Commission chair Hasyim Asy’ari said a disputed rule in a 2023 election regulation was discussed and approved at a meeting with lawmakers and other election bodies.
He denied allegations that the rule was inserted without discussion or manipulated.
Hasyim said Ahmad Doli Kurnia, then chair of the House Commission II, attended and signed the meeting’s conclusions.
Doli had said the rule was not discussed by the commission and the election commission.
Hasyim said there was no record of participants objecting to the rule.
- Who
- Former Election Commission chair Hasyim Asy’ari and former House Commission II chair Ahmad Doli Kurnia.
- What
- Hasyim said a disputed election rule was discussed and approved, disputing Doli’s claim that it was not discussed.
- When
- The rule was discussed on 20 September 2023. Hasyim made his statement on 12 October, according to the article.
- Where
- At a House Commission II hearing in Indonesia.
- Why
- Hasyim said he was responding to claims that the rule had not been discussed and was inserted without proper process.
Hasyim Asy’ari
Ahmad Doli Kurnia
Whether the rule was discussed
Hasyim Asy’ari
Hasyim said the disputed provision was discussed at the hearing on the draft regulation.
Ahmad Doli Kurnia
Doli said the provision was not discussed by the Election Commission with House Commission II.
Whether the rule was approved
Hasyim Asy’ari
Hasyim said the meeting’s conclusions, including the draft regulation, were approved and signed by participants.
Ahmad Doli Kurnia
Doli’s reported claim was that the provision was not discussed; the article does not state his view on whether it was approved.
It is not true that the provision was smuggled in or manipulated.
Forgetting is allowed, hypocrisy is not.
The Election Commission wrote to the House seeking consultations on four draft regulations and attached the drafts.
A hearing was held to consult on draft regulations, including the draft containing the disputed provision.
Hasyim said the provision had been discussed and approved at the hearing.
- Rule
- Article 18(3) of Election Commission Regulation No. 19 of 2023
- Meeting date
- 20 September 2023
- Drafts submitted
- Four draft regulations
- Hearing participant
- Ahmad Doli Kurnia, then chair of House Commission II
- Approval document
- Meeting conclusions signed by representatives of the House, Election Commission, Bawaslu, DKPP and the Home Affairs Ministry











