6 hrs ago
Supreme Court Rejects Tamil Nadu Plea Over Navodaya Schools
The Supreme Court is considering whether Navodaya schools should be built in every district of Tamil Nadu.
The court told the state to find land for the schools within three months.
Tamil Nadu does not want the schools because it worries they could encourage Hindi over Tamil.
The state said the policy is optional and that courts should not force it to follow the policy.
The Supreme Court said the schools are not against Tamil Nadu’s policy.
It also said Hindi cannot be kept out of the state.
The court asked Tamil Nadu and the central government to discuss the language issue.
The case will be heard again on December 14.
The Supreme Court rejected Tamil Nadu’s request to recall an interim order on identifying land for Navodaya schools.
The court directed the state to find land in every district within three months.
Tamil Nadu argued the schools could promote Hindi and undermine the state’s language policy favoring Tamil.
The court said Hindi cannot be kept out of Tamil Nadu and urged talks with the Centre through cooperative federalism.
Tamil Nadu is the only state without a Navodaya school; the next hearing is scheduled for December 14.
- Who
- The Supreme Court of India, the Tamil Nadu government, the Centre, Justice B. V. Nagarathna, and lawyers representing the state.
- What
- The Supreme Court rejected Tamil Nadu’s plea to recall an interim order requiring it to identify land for Navodaya schools in every district.
- Where
- Tamil Nadu, with the matter being heard by the Supreme Court.
- When
- The ruling was made during a hearing; the next hearing is scheduled for December 14, and the land must be identified within three months.
- Why
- Tamil Nadu opposes the schools because it fears they would promote Hindi and make it predominant over Tamil, while the court says the issue should be addressed through dialogue.
Tamil Nadu’s Position
Supreme Court’s Position
Language impact
Tamil Nadu’s Position
The state argues that Navodaya schools could make Hindi predominant over Tamil and conflict with Tamil Nadu’s language policy.
Supreme Court’s Position
The court said Hindi cannot be kept out of the state and that the schools are not against Tamil Nadu’s policy.
Whether implementation can be required
Tamil Nadu’s Position
Tamil Nadu says the policy is optional and courts cannot force a state to implement it.
Supreme Court’s Position
The court said Tamil Nadu cannot simply refuse to accept a central government policy and urged dialogue with the Centre.
Way forward
Tamil Nadu’s Position
The state has challenged the order requiring land to be identified for the schools.
Supreme Court’s Position
The court rejected the request to recall its interim order and told the state to find land within three months.
Key facts
- Court decision
- The Supreme Court declined to recall its interim order.
- Deadline
- Tamil Nadu was told to find land within three months.
- Proposed schools
- Navodaya Vidyalayas are proposed for every district in Tamil Nadu.
- State’s objection
- Tamil Nadu says the schools could impose Hindi and weaken Tamil’s position.
- Court’s observation
- The court said Hindi cannot be kept out of Tamil Nadu.
- Next hearing
- December 14.
- Current status
- Tamil Nadu is described as the only state without a single Navodaya school.
Quotes
The Supreme Court
India’s apex court, which heard Tamil Nadu’s challenge concerning Navodaya schools
“Hindi cannot be kept out of the state's soil”
NDTV
Sources
Related news
Supreme Court Gives Tamil Nadu Three Months for School Land
Supreme Court Tells Tamil Nadu Hindi Cannot Be Kept Out
Tamil Nadu Language Push Meets Court Relief for Protest Student
Tamil Nadu Assembly Seeks Tamil as Madras High Court Language
Supreme Court Asks CBSE to Revisit Three-Language Policy Rollout
Vijay to Seek Centre Approval for Tamil in High Courts
Collegium Extends Six Calcutta HC Judges’ Tenure Six Months
Supreme Court Seeks Replies Over MP Medical Scholarship Dispute
Supreme Court Collegium Recommends New Rajasthan High Court Chief Justice
