3 weeks ago
Is Vomiting the Body's Defence Mechanism? Experts Weigh In
Our bodies sometimes throw up, and two experts have different ideas about why.
One expert, a nutritionist named Dimple Jangda, says vomiting is like an alarm system that helps push out bad things we ate.
She says when you feel sick to your stomach, it is your body trying to protect you.
Another expert, a dietitian named Dr Sneha, agrees vomiting can help, but not every time you throw up is because of poison.
She says people can vomit because of headaches, pregnancy, medicine, or other health problems.
Dr Sneha also says there is no proof that stopping your nausea makes bad things come out another way.
She thinks medicine to stop vomiting is safe when doctors say it is okay.
Both experts say throwing up too much can make you lose water and important body salts.
They agree that if someone throws up a lot, has a fever, or has blood in their vomit, they should see a doctor right away.
Gut health expert Dimple Jangda said in an Instagram post that vomiting is the body's first line of defence against harmful substances.
Jangda argued that suppressing nausea does not stop the body from expelling toxins, which instead exit through a 'messier exit.'
Clinical dietitian Dr Sneha of Maccure Hospital said vomiting is a protective reflex, but not every episode is caused by toxins or infections.
Dr Sneha noted vomiting can stem from migraines, pregnancy, medications or neurological conditions, and called Jangda's claim an oversimplification with no strong scientific backing.
Dr Sneha said urgent care is needed for persistent vomiting, severe abdominal pain, high fever, blood in vomit or stool, dehydration, confusion, or symptoms lasting over 24–48 hours.
- Who
- Nutritionist and gut health expert Dimple Jangda and clinical dietitian Dr Sneha of Maccure Hospital.
- What
- A discussion over whether vomiting is the body's natural defence against toxins and whether nausea should be suppressed or allowed to run its course.
- Where
- On Instagram, through Jangda's post, and in expert commentary reported by a health news article.
- When
- No specific date is given in the article; Jangda's claims reference a 2021 review in the International Journal of Molecular Sciences.
- Why
- To clarify when vomiting is a protective reflex, whether suppressing nausea is harmful, and when vomiting becomes a medical emergency.
Trust the Body's Instinct
Consider Medical Context
Is vomiting always a toxin-removal response?
Trust the Body's Instinct
Jangda calls nausea 'Mother Nature's oldest alarm system' — when poison enters, the brain fires a warning and the body acts, with 'no debate, no delay.'
Consider Medical Context
Dr Sneha says the idea is accurate only to an extent; vomiting can also be caused by migraines, pregnancy, medications or neurological conditions, not toxins alone.
Does suppressing nausea harm the body?
Trust the Body's Instinct
Jangda says a suppressed signal does not disappear — the body still gets the poison out, just through a 'messier exit.'
Consider Medical Context
Dr Sneha calls this an oversimplification, noting there is no strong science that suppressing nausea forces toxins out another way, and anti-nausea medications are used safely when clinically indicated.
Key facts
- Health expert
- Dimple Jangda (nutritionist and gut health expert)
- Medical expert
- Dr Sneha (Clinical Dietitian, Maccure Hospital)
- Platform
- Core claim
- Vomiting is the body's first line of defence against harmful substances
- Other causes of vomiting
- Migraines, pregnancy, medications, neurological conditions
- Cited evidence
- 2021 review in the International Journal of Molecular Sciences
- Emergency warning signs
- Severe abdominal pain, persistent vomiting, high fever, blood in vomit or stool, dehydration, confusion
- When to seek care
- Symptoms lasting longer than 24–48 hours
Quotes
Dimple Jangda
Nutritionist and gut health expert
“Vomiting is not the result of toxins and infections alone. It can also be caused by migraines, pregnancy, medications or neurological conditions, therefore, it is essential to consult a healthcare provider if you suspect other reasons for vomiting.”
indianexpress.com
“If it persists, or there are signs of severe dehydration, blood in the vomit, chest pain, severe abdominal pain or confusion, a thorough medical assessment is necessary.”
indianexpress.com







