3 weeks ago
Investigation finds tech fund conflicts: 62% lent to panel-linked firms
The Indian government created a very big pot of money called the Research, Development and Innovation fund to help new technology companies grow.
Recently, the fund gave about Rs 2,192 crore to 22 companies working on space, energy, and medicine.
A small group of seven experts decides which companies should get the money.
A newspaper called The Indian Express checked where this money actually went.
It found that many of the companies that got money had connections to the experts on that panel.
In fact, about 62 percent of the money went to companies that were linked to panel members.
The chairman of the panel, Saurabh Srivastava, was connected to nine of the funded companies.
The government says all the choices were fair and made 'purely on merit.'
The experts say they must tell everyone about their business connections and step away when those companies are discussed.
This way, people can decide for themselves whether the process is fair or needs more rules.
India's new deep tech innovation fund gave Rs 2,192 crore to 22 firms in its first round, covering space tech, energy and pharma sectors.
Fifteen of the 22 recipients have investment ties to seven selection panel members, totalling over Rs 1,377 crore.
Nearly two-thirds (62%) of the over Rs 2,000 crore lent went to companies tied to members of the panel that decided where the money went.
Panel chairman Saurabh Srivastava, an angel investor, is linked to nine funded firms, including a personal stake in Noccarc Robotics.
The government says selections were 'purely on merit' with zero conflicted-member involvement in evaluation or sanction decisions.
- Who
- The Indian Express investigation team (Deputy Editor Amitabh Sinha and National Bureau Chief Sandeep Singh), selection panel members including chairman Saurabh Srivastava, and Congress MP Praveen Chakravarty.
- What
- An investigation found that about 62% of the RDI fund's first-round funding went to companies with ties to the panel that decided where the money went.
- Where
- India
- When
- Late last month, after an Opposition lawmaker's parliamentary question; the fund itself was established the previous year.
- Why
- To determine whether enough guardrails existed for the Rs 1 lakh crore fund's soft loans to private companies.
Calls for scrutiny of conflict of interest
Process defended as fair and safeguarded
Ties between panel members and funded firms
Calls for scrutiny of conflict of interest
62% of the money went to companies connected to panel members, so the nature of the associations and the financial stakes should be examined closely.
Process defended as fair and safeguarded
Experts chosen from the private sector are expected to have ties to private firms; a panel of the sharpest minds in technology and investment would naturally know these companies.
Adequacy of safeguards
Calls for scrutiny of conflict of interest
The guardrails for Rs 1 lakh crore of public money need verification, and the investigation went beyond the government's parliamentary response to uncover financial interests.
Process defended as fair and safeguarded
The process includes mandatory disclosure and recusal of any panel member linked to a firm under consideration, and selections were 'purely on merit' with zero conflicted-member involvement.
Key facts
- Fund
- Research, Development and Innovation (RDI) fund
- Fund size
- Rs 1 lakh crore
- First-round disbursement
- Rs 2,192 crore to 22 firms
- Panel-linked share
- 62%, over Rs 1,377 crore to 15 of 22 firms
- Sectors funded
- Space tech, energy and pharma
- Panel chairman
- Saurabh Srivastava, linked to nine funded firms
- Investigation trigger
- Congress MP Praveen Chakravarty's parliamentary query
- Government position
- Selections 'purely on merit'; enough safeguards in place
Quotes
Gopal Srinivasan, Chairman and Managing Director, TVS Capitals Fund
Chairman and Managing Director of TVS Capitals Fund
“I think this is a fair question to ask. And it is good that this is being discussed in the public domain. The whole purpose of the RDI (Rs 1‑lakh‑crore Research, Development and Innovation) fund is to enable access to long‑term risk capital to companies engaged in novel and promising technology development, ideally strategic for sovereign ownership. And there is very active private participation in this process. In fact, the suggestion for establishing the RDI fund had also come from the private”
indianexpress.com








