2 hrs ago

Election Commission Rift Raises Questions Over Electoral Safeguards

Election Commission Rift Raises Questions Over Electoral Safeguards
What Election Commission rift reveals: Cloud over its conduct · indianexpress.com

The Election Commission helps decide who can vote.

Two of its members say important decisions were made without properly consulting them.

They also say a computer system controlled from Delhi stopped a Goa officer from recording 97 people as eligible voters.

This could mean that someone who proves they can vote still might not appear on the voter list.

The Commissioners objected to a new form asking new voters about their parents’ and grandparents’ past voter-list records.

They say this could make a parent’s disputed record affect a child’s registration.

They are also worried that too much control has moved from local election officers to a central team.

Earlier disagreements inside the Commission focused on individual issues, but these objections concern how the institution itself is working.

The article says this has raised concerns about safeguards for elections.

Key facts

Commissioners raising objections
Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi
Goa case
97 people were found eligible by an Electoral Registration Officer, but the software did not permit the decisions to be recorded.
Form affected
Form-6, used in the registration of new voters
Central control
The article says the voter-roll software is controlled from Election Commission headquarters in Delhi.
Constitutional structure
The Election Commission is a three-member constitutional body.
Decision-making rule
The law says its business should, as far as possible, be conducted unanimously, with majority decisions when members differ.
Earlier dissent
The article cites disputes involving N Gopalaswami and Navin Chawla in 2009, and Ashok Lavasa and Sunil Arora in 2019.

Quotes

Sunil Arora

Former Chief Election Commissioner who responded to Ashok Lavasa’s 2019 dissent over Model Code of Conduct decisions.

“not expected to be templates or clones of each other”
indianexpress.com

Sources

Related news