3 weeks ago
Smriti Irani: Jantar Mantar Protest Was a Machiavellian Playbook
A big leader from the BJP party, Smriti Irani, talked about a big protest that happened last month in New Delhi, at a famous place called Jantar Mantar.
She said the protest was not really about young people, but was planned and brought together by many different political groups.
She said some of those groups included the ultra-left, the Left, liberal groups, the Aam Aadmi Party and the INDIA bloc.
She also said that at the protest people shouted 'Azadi' and were rude to the army, the courts and other important institutions.
Mrs. Irani said young people in India serve the country as soldiers, doctors, engineers and in the police, and that they should not be blamed for that protest.
She compared the Delhi protest with peaceful student protests in Jharkhand, Mumbai and Pune, where no one abused the armed forces.
She praised the peaceful students and said abuse of institutions and the armed forces can never be accepted.
She also said the Prime Minister has answered young people's real problems and has always talked to them on Instagram.
She said the leader of the opposition did not go to the protest but only wanted his own photo opportunities.
In the end, she said protests are fine as long as people respect the country and its forces.
Smriti Irani called the Jantar Mantar protest a 'Machiavellian playbook', describing it as an assimilation of political groups rather than a Gen Z movement.
She named the ultra-left, the Left, liberal groups, the Aam Aadmi Party and INDIA bloc members among those who gathered at Jantar Mantar.
Irani alleged that protesters raised 'Azadi' slogans and abused institutions, including the judiciary, and the armed forces.
She praised protests in Jharkhand, Mumbai and Pune as peaceful, saying students there did not abuse the armed forces or use controversial slogans.
She accused the Leader of Opposition of avoiding Jantar Mantar while seeking his own 'photo ops', and defended the Prime Minister's Instagram engagement with youth.
- Who
- BJP leader Smriti Irani, speaking about the Jantar Mantar protesters (whom she described as political groups, not Gen Z), the Leader of Opposition, the Prime Minister and activist Saurav Das of CJP.
- What
- Irani called the Jantar Mantar protest a 'Machiavellian playbook', alleging it was an assimilation of political groups that abused institutions and the armed forces.
- Where
- Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, with references to protests in Jharkhand, Mumbai and Pune.
- When
- The Jantar Mantar protest took place in New Delhi last month; Irani's remarks came in a recent NDTV interview.
- Why
- To dispute that the protest represented Gen Z, defend the government's response, and distinguish peaceful protests from those that abuse institutions.
Critics of the Government
BJP and Government Supporters
Nature of the Jantar Mantar protest
Critics of the Government
The congregation was genuinely an assembly of Gen Z, reflecting the concerns of an entire young generation.
BJP and Government Supporters
It was an assimilation of various political groups presenting themselves as a pressure group, and presuming it was Gen Z is wrong (Smriti Irani).
Comparison between protests
Critics of the Government
The protest-vs-protest binary is a 'trap' being set to pit one set of protesters against the other (CJP's Saurav Das).
BJP and Government Supporters
Jantar Mantar protesters beat up police, raised 'Azadi' slogans and abused institutions, while Jharkhand, Mumbai and Pune students protested respectfully and deserve praise (Smriti Irani).
Prime Minister's Instagram engagement
Critics of the Government
The protest forced the Prime Minister to take to Instagram to respond to youth.
BJP and Government Supporters
The PM has always been on Instagram and engaging with people; being responsive is a good quality (Smriti Irani).
Key facts
- Speaker
- Smriti Irani, BJP leader, in an NDTV interview
- Event
- Jantar Mantar protest, New Delhi (last month)
- Irani's Core Claim
- Protest was a 'Machiavellian playbook' and an assimilation of political groups, not a Gen Z movement
- Political Groups Named
- Ultra-left, the Left, liberal groups, Aam Aadmi Party, INDIA bloc
- Alleged Protest Conduct
- 'Azadi' slogans; abuse of institutions, judiciary and armed forces
- Contrast Cited
- Jharkhand, Mumbai and Pune protests had no violence or abuse of the armed forces
- Leader of Opposition
- Accused of avoiding Jantar Mantar while seeking his own photo ops
- Prime Minister
- Said to have responded to Gen Z's genuine grievances and engaged via Instagram
Quotes
Smriti Irani
BJP MP and minister
“"What we saw at Jantar Mantar was an assimilation of various political groups that were presenting themselves as a pressure group. There was the ultra-left, the Left, liberal groups, the Aam Aadmi Party and some from the INDIA bloc. To presume that it was an assimilation of Gen Z is to belie the fact that is staring us in the face."”
NDTV








