2 weeks ago
Derek O'Brien alleges censorship as 200-plus Parliament questions disallowed
Derek O'Brien is a politician who works in India's Parliament, the place where the country's leaders make decisions.
In Parliament, politicians are allowed to ask the government questions about important topics.
O'Brien says that more than 200 of his questions were stopped and not allowed to be asked.
He calls this 'censorship,' which means stopping people from sharing or asking information.
He showed a picture from a government website with 207 questions marked as 'disallowed.'
His questions were about serious things like terrorist attacks, people losing their jobs, and hate crimes.
Other politicians, like Manish Tewari and Vivek Tankha from the Congress party, said the same thing happened to some of their questions.
Another politician named V S Matheswaran also said his questions about student protests were stopped.
Many politicians think this is unfair, because asking questions is how they make sure the government is doing its job.
They want the government to answer their questions so the people of India can know the truth.
TMC Rajya Sabha MP Derek O'Brien alleged over 200 questions he raised since 2021 were disallowed in Parliament, calling it 'censorship! inside and outside Parliament.'
He shared a Digital Sansad portal screenshot showing 207 entries under the 'disallowed' category, spanning topics like terrorist attacks, IT job losses, and hate crimes.
Congress MPs Manish Tewari and Vivek Tankha made similar claims: Tewari said 120-plus of his questions were disallowed, while Tankha got answers to fewer than 10 of about 90 questions.
O'Brien also alleged the Union government sent a blocking order to social media firms every minute from March to July.
The Cockroach Janata Party said questions by DMK MP V S Matheswaran on youth protests and NEET-UG refunds were disallowed in the Monsoon Session; Matheswaran confirmed this.
- Who
- TMC Rajya Sabha MP Derek O'Brien, alongside Congress MPs Manish Tewari and Vivek Tankha and DMK MP V S Matheswaran
- What
- Alleged that hundreds of their parliamentary questions were disallowed, calling it censorship inside and outside Parliament
- Where
- Indian Parliament (Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha), with details shown on the Digital Sansad website
- When
- Reported on a Tuesday, a day after similar claims by Congress MPs; the disallowed questions date from 2021 onwards
- Why
- MPs say the disallowances silence opposition scrutiny of the government on sensitive issues such as terrorist attacks, job losses, and hate crimes
Opposition MPs
Parliamentary rules / Union government
Disallowed questions
Opposition MPs
O'Brien and other opposition MPs describe the routine disallowance of hundreds of questions on terror attacks, IT job losses, and hate crimes as censorship inside Parliament.
Parliamentary rules / Union government
The disallowances cite Rule 47(2) grounds, such as questions not being pointed and specific, seeking secret information, or raising policy too large to answer within a question.
Scope of censorship
Opposition MPs
O'Brien alleges censorship extends outside Parliament, with the Union government sending a blocking order to social media firms every minute from March to July.
Parliamentary rules / Union government
The article contains no stated government explanation for the social media blocking orders, and the allegation is not addressed or confirmed in the reports.
Key facts
- Main allegation
- Over 200 questions by Derek O'Brien since 2021 disallowed in Parliament
- O'Brien's portal screenshot
- 207 entries under 'disallowed' on Digital Sansad
- Topics covered
- Terrorist attacks, IT sector job losses, hate crimes, Red Fort blast, NHRC status
- Rule cited
- Rule 47(2) of parliamentary procedures (e.g., 47(2)(i), 47(2)(xxii))
- Manish Tewari's claim
- Over 120 questions disallowed between September 2020 and August 2025
- Vivek Tankha's claim
- Fewer than 10 answers received for about 90 questions submitted
- DMK MP claim (via CJP)
- V S Matheswaran's questions on youth protests disallowed in Monsoon Session
- Social media claim
- O'Brien alleged a blocking order to social media firms every minute from March to July









