1 day ago
Gujarat High Court Reprimands Journalist Over Undisclosed Bail Plea
Journalist Ravi Nair was involved in a criminal defamation case filed by Adani Enterprises.
A lower court had sentenced him to one year in prison.
While appealing that decision, he missed a hearing because his lawyers said he was unwell and had to travel from Kerala.
The appellate court rejected his request to skip appearing in person and issued a warrant for his arrest.
Nair was later arrested and his lawyers asked the High Court to intervene.
They also asked a lower court for bail, which granted it on September 24.
The High Court criticized the lawyers for not telling it about that bail request.
The court said people asking for special help must openly share all important facts.
Since Nair had already received bail, the High Court closed the petition without deciding the main legal issues.
The Gujarat High Court criticized journalist Ravi Nair for not disclosing a lower-court bail application while seeking an urgent hearing.
Nair was arrested after a non-bailable warrant followed his failure to personally appear in an appeal hearing.
A Mansa court sentenced Nair to one year in prison in a criminal defamation case filed by Adani Enterprises.
A Gandhinagar appellate court granted Nair bail on September 24 after his arrest.
The High Court disposed of Nair’s petition without ruling on its merits because bail had already been granted.
- Who
- Journalist Ravi Nair, his lawyers, the Gujarat High Court, and Adani Enterprises.
- What
- The High Court reprimanded Nair’s counsel for not disclosing a lower-court bail application and disposed of his petition after bail was granted.
- Where
- The proceedings involved the Gujarat High Court and appellate and trial courts in Gandhinagar and Mansa, Gujarat.
- When
- The relevant proceedings occurred in September; the appellate court granted bail on September 24.
- Why
- Nair sought relief after being arrested under a non-bailable warrant issued when he did not personally appear at an appeal hearing.
Court’s Disclosure Standard
Nair’s Legal Position
Failure to disclose the bail request
Court’s Disclosure Standard
The High Court said Nair’s lawyers should have told it that they had also sought bail from the appellate court, even if that fact could weaken their case.
Nair’s Legal Position
Nair’s lawyers simultaneously pursued relief in the High Court and bail in the appellate court; the lower court ultimately granted bail on September 24.
Absence from the appeal hearing
Court’s Disclosure Standard
The appellate court rejected Nair’s request for exemption from personal appearance and issued a non-bailable warrant after he failed to attend.
Nair’s Legal Position
Nair’s lawyers said he could not appear because of poor health and because he had to travel from his native state, Kerala.
Key facts
- Journalist
- Ravi Nair
- Company filing the case
- Adani Enterprises
- Trial-court sentence
- One year imprisonment
- Arrest basis
- A non-bailable warrant issued after Nair failed to appear personally at an appeal hearing
- Bail date
- September 24, according to the article
- High Court outcome
- Petition disposed of without a ruling on the merits
- Disclosure principle
- The court said parties invoking extraordinary jurisdiction must disclose all material facts openly
Quotes
Gujarat High Court
The court hearing Ravi Nair’s petition against his arrest
“As settled law held by the apex court...a party invoking extraordinary jurisdiction of this court is expected to approach the court with utmost candour, frankness and openness.”
rediff.com
Sources
Related news
Gujarat High Court Denies Relief to Journalist Ravi Nair
Journalist Ravi Nair Gets Bail in Adani Defamation Case
Gujarat High Court Gives Adani More Time in Nair Case
Ravi Nair Jailed After Warrant, Challenges Process in Gujarat
Bombay High Court Rejects Gandhi Plea in Modi Defamation Case
Rajasthan High Court Grants Meena Bail in SDM Case
Ahmedabad Metro Plans New Thaltej Gam–Godhavi Route
Former Gujarat CM Vaghela In Talks To Rejoin Congress
Supreme Court Reviews Trial Fairness, Not Amit Shah’s Discharge
Congress Moves Candidates To Safe Location Before Gandhinagar Civic Polls