Politics · Italy · 8 hrs ago
Cacciari says Italy’s centre-left may need a third candidate to lead its coalition
Massimo Cacciari, a philosopher and former mayor of Venice, has criticised the debate over how Italy’s centre-left should choose a coalition leader.
He says the coalition should not assume that Democratic Party leader Elly Schlein will lead it just because her party is its largest.
Cacciari points to Giorgia Meloni, whose party grew from a small force to the largest on the right, as a leader whose position is established by her political record.
He says the centre-left could instead agree on a third candidate, as it did when Romano Prodi ran for prime minister without leading a party.
Cacciari also argues that writing a shared programme will not resolve deep differences between opposition parties, including over foreign policy.
He warns that primaries between Schlein and Five Star Movement leader Giuseppe Conte could deepen those divisions and discourage some voters.
He says primaries make sense only when the parties already agree on the main political issues.
Massimo Cacciari said Italy’s centre-left may need a third person, rather than party leader Elly Schlein, to lead its coalition.
He argued that agreeing on a common programme before choosing a leader would not resolve the coalition’s major disagreements.
Cacciari questioned the value of primaries, saying they could deepen divisions over issues such as foreign policy.
He contrasted Schlein’s position with Giorgia Meloni’s, saying Meloni had demonstrated political ability while Schlein still had to prove herself.
- Who
- Philosopher Massimo Cacciari discussed the centre-left coalition and its potential leadership.
- What
- He said the coalition could agree on a third candidate to lead it and criticised proposals to settle its programme before choosing a leader.
- When
- The interview was published on 12 October 2026.
- Where
- Cacciari spoke on 24 Mattino, a programme on Radio24.
- Why
- He said the centre-left has serious disagreements on economic, social and foreign-policy issues that a shared programme or primary might not resolve.
Cacciari
Supporters of agreeing a programme before choosing a leader
Programme and leadership
Cacciari
Cacciari called the debate over writing a common programme before selecting a leader unserious and said the coalition could instead find a third candidate.
Supporters of agreeing a programme before choosing a leader
They favour settling on a common programme before choosing the coalition’s candidate.
Primaries
Cacciari
Cacciari said primaries could deepen divisions and leave voters disappointed.
Supporters of agreeing a programme before choosing a leader
The article describes primaries as a proposed way to choose the coalition’s leader.
Cacciari said Meloni’s political force had 4–5% support.
Cacciari discussed centre-left leadership and coalition disagreements on 24 Mattino on Radio24.
- Interviewee
- Massimo Cacciari
- Programme
- 24 Mattino on Radio24
- Publication date
- 12 October 2026
- Meloni’s political force 10 years earlier
- 4–5% support
- Potential candidate
- A third name, which Cacciari said could be little known politically
What people are saying
Schlein must still prove absolutely everything
The contradictions within the right are absolutely analogous to those within the broad coalition
They are nonsense!










