3 weeks ago
Medical equipment worth crores found unused at Delhi government hospitals
The Delhi High Court is like a very important judge's office.
It learned that some government hospitals in Delhi had expensive machines that were not being used.
The court asked all government hospitals to check their equipment and report back.
The check found machines worth crores of rupees, which is a huge amount of money, just sitting unused.
One very costly machine, called a cyclotron, helps take pictures inside the body to find cancer.
It has not been used since April 2022 because there are not enough trained people to run it.
Hospitals gave different reasons, like not enough workers, no special doctors, or no space to set up the machines.
The court said this is a big waste of people's money.
The government has to explain what happened and find a way to fix it.
An audit ordered by the Delhi High Court on July 3 found crores of rupees worth of medical equipment lying unused at 26 Delhi government hospitals.
A USD 2.5 million (about Rs 15.42 crore) medical cyclotron at Delhi State Cancer Institute has been unused since April 2022 due to lack of manpower.
The High Court bench of Justices Prathiba Singh and Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora recorded that the situation is 'a gross waste of public resources.'
Hospitals cited lack of manpower, non-availability of radiologists, lack of installation space, and discontinuation of reagents as reasons for the unused equipment.
The Delhi government compiled the hospital audit reports in an affidavit submitted before the High Court on August 5.
- Who
- Delhi High Court judges Prathiba Singh and Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora ordered the audit; 26 Delhi government hospitals, including Delhi State Cancer Institute, Deen Dayal Upadhyay Hospital, and Lok Nayak Hospital, were involved.
- What
- An audit found medical equipment worth crores of rupees, including a cyclotron, imaging devices, analysers, and ventilators, lying unused in Delhi government hospitals.
- Where
- Government hospitals in Delhi, India.
- When
- The court order was issued on July 3; the Delhi government's affidavit was submitted on August 5; the cyclotron has been unused since April 2022.
- Why
- Cited reasons include lack of manpower, non-availability of radiologists, lack of installation space, and discontinued reagents; the court described the situation as a gross waste of public resources.
Court's Accountability View
Hospitals' Operational Constraints View
Cause of unused equipment
Court's Accountability View
The Delhi High Court recorded that idle public-funded equipment is 'a gross waste of public resources,' indicating mismanagement and failure to utilize expensive medical assets.
Hospitals' Operational Constraints View
Hospitals cite reasons largely outside their control, including lack of manpower, no regular radiologist posts, lack of installation space, discontinued reagents, and pandemic-related shutdowns; some items are kept for use 'when required.'
Key facts
- Hospitals audited
- 26
- Cyclotron cost
- USD 2.5 million (about Rs 15.42 crore)
- Cyclotron unused since
- April 2022
- Court order date
- July 3
- Affidavit submission date
- August 5
- Biochemistry analyser cost
- Rs 1.26 crore
- Oxygen buffer tank cost
- Rs 94.82 lakh (donated by Save Life Foundation in 2021)
- Dhaman ventilators unused
- 13 units at Rs 2.16 lakh each
Quotes
Justice Prathiba Singh
Delhi High Court judge
“It is clear that this is a gross waste of public resources”
indianexpress.com







