2 hrs ago
Kerala Cleric’s Women’s Views Split Chief Minister, Ally
A religious leader in Kerala said women should stay at home and avoid mixing with unrelated men in public.
He made the comment after women took part in Eid Milad-un-Nabi celebrations.
Kerala Chief Minister V D Satheesan disagreed with him.
Satheesan said women should be able to take part in all parts of public life.
He also said the Quran was being interpreted incorrectly.
A leader of the Indian Union Muslim League defended the religious leader and said he may have been thinking about women’s safety.
Some Muslim scholars agreed with the cleric, while many Muslim women criticized the view online.
Muslim women in Kerala have increasingly participated in celebrations, elections, and public jobs.
Fathima Thahilya recently became the first woman legislator elected from the IUML in Kerala.
Kerala Chief Minister V D Satheesan rejected cleric Kanthapuram A P Aboobacker Musliyar’s call for women to remain confined to their homes.
Satheesan said Muslim women should participate fully in mainstream public life and argued that the Quran was being misinterpreted.
Indian Union Muslim League leader Panakkad Sayyid Sadiq Ali Shihab Thangal defended the cleric, saying the restrictions might be intended to protect women.
Muslim scholars and conservative groups backed Kanthapuram, while Muslim women on social media criticized his position.
The dispute comes as Muslim women’s participation in Kerala’s political and social life continues to grow, including the election of IUML’s first woman legislator, Fathima Thahilya.
- Who
- Kerala Chief Minister V D Satheesan, cleric Kanthapuram A P Aboobacker Musliyar, and Indian Union Muslim League leaders are central to the dispute.
- What
- They disagree over whether Muslim women should remain confined to their homes or participate freely in public life.
- Where
- Kerala, India.
- When
- The dispute followed last week’s Eid Milad-un-Nabi celebrations; Satheesan responded on Wednesday, shortly after the IUML endorsed the cleric’s position.
- Why
- Kanthapuram said women’s public interaction with unrelated men was un-Islamic, while Satheesan said women should participate in mainstream society and that the Quran was being misinterpreted.
Progressive participation
Religious restrictions and protection
Women in public life
Progressive participation
Satheesan said women should live in mainstream society and participate in all activities, calling the cleric’s position unsuitable for progressive Kerala.
Religious restrictions and protection
Kanthapuram said women should remain confined to their homes and that their presence among unrelated men in public was un-Islamic.
Religious interpretation
Progressive participation
Satheesan argued that the Quran was being misinterpreted and cited Khadija, Aisha, Bilkis, and a woman who challenged a decision in Caliph Umar’s assembly as examples of women’s public roles.
Religious restrictions and protection
Kanthapuram invoked Quranic teaching in support of women remaining at home; IUML leader Panakkad Sayyid Sadiq Ali Shihab Thangal defended the position as one that might be intended for women’s benefit and safety.
Political and social direction
Progressive participation
Muslim women’s participation in Onam celebrations, elections, public posts, and political campaigning reflects a continuing expansion of their role in Kerala’s public life.
Religious restrictions and protection
Conservative Muslim elements and some scholars have continued to warn against women entering public spaces, including criticizing women appearing on stages or contesting elections.
Key facts
- Central disagreement
- Whether Muslim women should be confined to their homes or participate in public activities.
- Chief minister’s position
- V D Satheesan said women should take part in all mainstream social activities.
- Cleric’s position
- Kanthapuram A P Aboobacker Musliyar said women appearing in public among unrelated men was un-Islamic.
- IUML response
- Panakkad Sayyid Sadiq Ali Shihab Thangal defended the cleric and said the restrictions might be intended for women’s safety.
- Public reaction
- Muslim scholars and conservative groups supported Kanthapuram, while several Muslim women criticized his position on social media.
- Political development
- Fathima Thahilya became the first woman legislator of the Indian Union Muslim League in Kerala.
- Women’s representation
- The article says Muslim women have increasingly contested and won seats in Kerala’s local bodies after 50 percent reservation for women was introduced.
Quotes
Panakkad Sayyid Sadiq Ali Shihab Thangal
IUML state chief and religious leader who defended Kanthapuram’s statement.
“Neither Congress nor the government can agree to that stand. Such a thing should be stated in the 19th century, not in this 21st century. Women should live in mainstream society, taking part in all activities. We have a progressive stand on this. Kanthapuram quotes the Quran saying that women should remain confined to their homes and there would be disaster if they come to public space,”
indianexpress.com
“What is more important is the unity of the community as well as the society. The IUML stand is to remain close to that. Kanthapuram had stated so as a religious leader. The restrictions could be for the benefit of women. In modern society, women are the most targeted. He might have that scenario in his mind,”
indianexpress.com
Sources
Related news
IUML Defends Kanthapuram Remarks Amid Kerala Women’s Rights Row
CM Satheesan Rejects Kanthapuram's Call to Confine Women
Kerala Cleric’s Remarks on Women Draw Cross-Party Backlash
Kerala Leaders Condemn Scholar’s Remarks Restricting Women’s Public Roles
Cristiano Ronaldo’s Sister Elma Aveiro Meets Kerala Leader Satheesan
Cristiano Ronaldo’s Sister Meets Kerala CM, Carries Fans’ Message
Satheesan Targets CPI(M) Amid Kerala Election Defeat Fallout