1 week ago
Supreme Court Rejects Tejpal’s Exemption Plea, Orders Surrender Before Appeal
The Supreme Court said Tarun Tejpal must surrender before his appeal can be heard.
Tejpal had asked the court to let him wait before going into custody.
The court rejected that request.
It told him to report to authorities and provide proof of surrender.
His appeal may be listed on September 22 if he meets that requirement.
The appeal challenges a Bombay High Court conviction in a 2013 case involving a former colleague.
The High Court gave him a 10-year prison sentence after overturning an earlier acquittal.
The Goa government disagrees with the sentence and wants life imprisonment.
The Supreme Court rejected former Tehelka editor-in-chief Tarun Tejpal’s request to avoid surrendering before his appeal is heard.
Justice Alok Aradhe directed Tejpal to surrender and submit a surrender certificate, with most reports specifying a two-week deadline.
The court said his appeal against the conviction may be listed on September 22 if the certificate is filed by the required date.
The Bombay High Court convicted Tejpal on August 6 and sentenced him to 10 years of rigorous imprisonment, overturning a 2021 acquittal.
Tejpal is challenging the conviction, while the Goa government is seeking to increase his sentence to life imprisonment.
- Who
- Former Tehelka editor-in-chief Tarun Tejpal, the Supreme Court, Justice Alok Aradhe, and the Goa government.
- What
- The Supreme Court rejected Tejpal’s request for exemption from surrender and made surrender a condition for proceeding with his conviction appeal.
- Where
- The underlying case concerns an alleged assault inside a hotel elevator in Goa during a Tehelka event in November 2013; the Supreme Court hearing took place in New Delhi.
- When
- The order was issued on a Tuesday; the appeal may be listed on September 22. Most reports say surrender was required within two weeks, while one report says three weeks.
- Why
- The court applied the requirement that a convicted person surrender and submit a surrender certificate before the appeal can be heard, unless an exemption is granted.
Tejpal’s Position
Goa Government’s Position
Whether surrender should precede the appeal
Tejpal’s Position
Tejpal’s lawyers argued that the Supreme Court could exempt him from surrendering and list or hear his appeal first, noting that the High Court had granted him time to surrender.
Goa Government’s Position
The Goa government argued that Tejpal must surrender and submit a surrender certificate, or obtain an exemption, before his appeal can be heard.
Challenge to the conviction
Tejpal’s Position
Tejpal’s appeal disputes the High Court’s assessment of the complainant’s account and cites CCTV footage, elevator operation, WhatsApp messages, emails, and witness testimony as allegedly inconsistent with the prosecution’s version.
Goa Government’s Position
The Goa government relies on the High Court’s conviction and characterization of the offence as aggravated rape, and is seeking life imprisonment instead of the 10-year sentence.
Interpretation of the earlier acquittal
Tejpal’s Position
Tejpal challenges the High Court’s decision to overturn the 2021 acquittal and has argued that the evidence was not properly assessed.
Goa Government’s Position
The Goa government argued that the trial court wrongly evaluated the evidence and focused on the complainant’s character and post-incident conduct.
Key facts
- Accused
- Tarun Tejpal, former editor-in-chief of Tehelka
- Underlying case
- Allegations that Tejpal sexually assaulted a junior colleague inside a hotel elevator in Goa during a 2013 event
- Bombay High Court ruling
- On August 6, the High Court overturned Tejpal’s 2021 acquittal and imposed 10 years of rigorous imprisonment
- Supreme Court direction
- Tejpal must surrender and file a surrender certificate before his appeal proceeds
- Appeal listing
- The appeal may be listed on September 22 if the surrender certificate is filed by the required date
- Tejpal’s appeal
- It challenges the High Court’s assessment of the complainant’s evidence, CCTV footage, elevator operation, messages, emails, and other testimony
- Goa government position
- It opposes exemption from surrender and has sought enhancement of the sentence to life imprisonment
Quotes
Supreme Court bench
The Supreme Court bench hearing Tejpal’s surrender and appeal application.
“The application seeking exemption from surrendering is rejected. However, the appellant (Tejpal) is granted three weeks’ time to surrender and file surrender certificate before this court.”
theprint.in
“if the Supreme Court held the view that Tejpal should not be granted relief, he was prepared to go into custody.”
NDTV
Sources
Supreme Court rejects Tarun Tejpal’s plea, asks him to surrender within 2 weeks
'Surrender within 2 weeks': SC rejects Tarun Tejpal's plea for exemption from surrender
Supreme Court Rejects Rape Convict Tarun Tejpal's Plea, Asks To Surrender Within 2 Weeks
Supreme Court rejects Tarun Tejpal's plea, orders him to surrender within two weeks in rape case
SC Rejects Tarun Tejpal’s Plea Against Surrender In 2013 Rape Case
SC tells journalist Tarun Tejpal to surrender within two weeks in 2013 rape case
SC directs Tejpal to surrender within 3 weeks, rejects plea for exemption
Tarun Tejpal Asked By Supreme Court To Surrender In Two Weeks
SC directs Tarun Tejpal to surrender in 2 weeks
Tarun Tejpal surrender plea rejected: Supreme Court orders former Tehelka editor to surrender within 2 weeks
Tarun Tejpal told to surrender within 3 weeks, Supreme Court to hear appeal thereafter - Telegraph India
Supreme Court Rejects Tarun Tejpal’s Plea Against Surrender, Orders Him To Give Himself Up Within 2 Weeks
Related news
Supreme Court to Hear Tejpal’s Surrender Exemption Plea
Solicitor General urges Tejpal surrender before Supreme Court appeal
Tejpal Challenges Bombay High Court Rape Conviction in Supreme Court
Tarun Tejpal Challenges Conviction as Goa Seeks Life Sentence
Tehelka Founder Tarun Tejpal Sentenced to 10 Years in Prison
Bombay High Court Convicts Tarun Tejpal in 2013 Rape Case
CJP Calls Off Delhi March After Supreme Court Order
Subhash Chandra Challenges Five-Member NCLT Bench in Insolvency Case
Supreme Court Limits Manan Mishra’s Pro Tem BCI Role
Subhash Chandra Challenges Five-Member Bench in Insolvency Case
Subhash Chandra Challenges NCLT Bench as NCLAT Appeal Waits
