10 months ago
Centre Directs Haryana to Hold DISHA Committee Meetings Independently
Imagine two important clubs for your town.
One club, called DISHA, checks if special programs from the national government are working well, and a state leader is in charge of it.
The other club listens to people's complaints, and the local Member of Parliament (MP) is in charge of that.
The Haryana government had told everyone to hold meetings for both clubs on the same day.
But an MP said this was a bad idea because the clubs have different jobs and a meeting can take a very long time.
He worried it would make it hard to do the important work.
So, the national government agreed and told Haryana to hold the meetings for each club separately, so they can do their jobs properly and efficiently.
The central government has instructed Haryana to hold DISHA Committee meetings independently.
This directive reverses a July order from the Haryana government for simultaneous meetings of DISHA and Grievance Redressal Committees.
Ambala Congress MP Varun Chaudhary raised objections, stating the state's order undermined the distinct mandates and roles of MPs.
The central ministry cited that joint meetings may not conform to DISHA's mandate and could be impractical, potentially affecting the quality of deliberations.
Union Rural Development Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan confirmed the ministry's communication to Haryana, emphasizing independent meetings align with guidelines for effective program monitoring.
- Who
- The central government (Union Ministry of Rural Development)
- What
- Directed the Haryana government to hold District Level Grievance Redressal Committee and DISHA Committee meetings independently, reversing a previous state order for simultaneous meetings.
- Where
- Haryana
- When
- On or before November 6, 2023, with the central government's communication to the state.
- Why
- To ensure conformity with the mandate of DISHA committees, which monitor central-sponsored schemes, and to address concerns that joint meetings were impractical and could undermine the role of MPs.
Key facts
- Central Government Direction
- Haryana must hold DISHA Committee meetings independently.
- Previous State Instruction
- Haryana previously ordered simultaneous meetings of DISHA and Grievance Redressal Committees.
- Reason for Central Intervention
- Objection raised by Ambala Congress MP Varun Chaudhary.
- DISHA Committee Mandate
- Monitor central-sponsored schemes, chaired by a state minister.
- Grievance Committee Mandate
- Listen to individuals' grievances, chaired by the MP.
- Union Rural Development Minister
- Shivraj Singh Chouhan
- Central Ministry's Concern
- Joint meetings may not conform to DISHA mandate and could be impractical.
Quotes
Varun Chaudhary
Ambala Congress MP
“The DISHA committee meetings, chaired by a state minister, monitor the central-sponsored schemes, while the Grievances Committee meetings, chaired by the MP concerned, are primarily for listening to individuals’ grievances.”
indianexpress.com
“The directions issued by the government of Haryana will lead to non-functioning of the DISHA Committee, and the objective of improvement in infrastructure, human development, and well-being of the people will get impaired.”
indianexpress.com
Shivraj Singh Chouhan
Union Rural Development Minister
“I hope to get your continued support in strengthening the DISHA monitoring system and for achieving the intended objective of the DISHA committee.”
indianexpress.com
“to ensure DISHA meetings are convened independently, in line with the guidelines, for effective monitoring of central programmes”
indianexpress.com
the Union ministry
the Union ministry
“convening DISHA meetings jointly with other committees may not be in conformity with the mandate of DISHA committees since they involve detailed review and discussion on multiple central schemes often lasting several hours”
indianexpress.com
“may not be practically feasible and could adversely affect the quality and focus of deliberations”
indianexpress.com
a section of Congress leaders
a section of Congress leaders
“encroachment on the rights of MPs”
indianexpress.com




