1 day ago
Satheesan’s Women’s Remarks Unite Kerala’s Rival Muslim Bodies
A senior Muslim cleric in Kerala said women should not mix with men in public during some religious activities.
V D Satheesan criticised this view and said women should participate fully in society.
He also said the Quran was being interpreted incorrectly.
Several Muslim organisations disagreed with Satheesan and defended the cleric.
Some said religious leaders, rather than politicians, should explain religious matters.
Rival Sunni groups that usually disagree therefore came together on this issue.
The Indian Union Muslim League also said the cleric may have been thinking about women’s safety.
However, some Muslims, including women, criticised the cleric.
The debate shows that Muslim women’s public and political participation is continuing to expand in Kerala.
Kanthapuram A P Abubacker Musliyar warned against women mingling with men in public places during Islamic celebrations.
V D Satheesan called the cleric’s position unsuitable for a progressive Kerala and accused him of misinterpreting the Quran.
The Keralam Muslim Jamaath, SAMASTHA and the IUML defended or supported Kanthapuram’s position.
The controversy temporarily united rival Sunni organisations that are usually divided politically, organisationally and ideologically.
Muslim women and reformist voices also criticised Kanthapuram, while women’s participation in Kerala’s public and political life continues to grow.
- Who
- Kanthapuram A P Abubacker Musliyar, V D Satheesan, rival Sunni organisations, the Indian Union Muslim League and Muslim critics.
- What
- A dispute over the cleric’s comments on women’s presence in public places became a broader debate over the interpretation of Islam.
- Where
- Kerala, referred to as Keralam in the reports.
- When
- The original controversy followed comments about Eid Milad-un-Nabi celebrations on August 26.
- Why
- Satheesan said women should participate in mainstream society, while Muslim organisations defended the cleric’s religious position and objected to political interpretations of Islam.
Progressive and Reformist View
Religious and Community-Unity View
Women in public life
Progressive and Reformist View
Satheesan argued that women should live in mainstream society and participate in all activities, calling restrictions on their public presence outdated.
Religious and Community-Unity View
Kanthapuram warned against women mingling with men in public places, while supporters said such restrictions might be intended for women’s safety.
Who should interpret religion
Progressive and Reformist View
Satheesan said the Quran was being misinterpreted and challenged the cleric’s interpretation of women’s role.
Religious and Community-Unity View
The Keralam Muslim Jamaath and SAMASTHA said politicians should not teach or interpret religion and that religious matters should be addressed by religious leaders.
Effect on the Muslim community
Progressive and Reformist View
Reformists and progressive elements used the controversy to challenge an influential cleric’s position on women.
Religious and Community-Unity View
Major Muslim organisations prioritised community unity and rallied behind Kanthapuram despite their usual political and organisational rivalry.
Key facts
- Cleric involved
- Kanthapuram A P Abubacker Musliyar, a 94-year-old Sunni Muslim cleric.
- Trigger
- His directive concerned women’s participation in Eid Milad-un-Nabi celebrations on August 26.
- Satheesan’s position
- He called the view unsuitable for a progressive Kerala and said women should take part in all social activities.
- Organisational response
- The Keralam Muslim Jamaath, SAMASTHA and the Indian Union Muslim League supported or defended Kanthapuram’s position.
- Community divisions
- The two leading Sunni factions have been organisationally and politically opposed since a 1989 split.
- Population
- Muslims account for 26% of Kerala’s population, according to the article.
- Continuing criticism
- Some Muslims, including women, criticised Kanthapuram, particularly on social media.
Quotes
Panakkad Sayyid Sadiq Ali Shihab Thangal
IUML state chief and religious leader
“Do not belittle those who speak on religious matters. Those related to religion will speak about religious matters. India is a country where people are allowed to speak about religion. Hence, those who speak about religion should not be belittled saying that their stand is not relevant to the contemporary period.”
indianexpress.com
“Neither Congress nor the government can agree to that stand. Such a thing should be stated in the 19th century, not in this 21st century. Women should live in mainstream society, taking part in all activities. We have a progressive stand on this.”
indianexpress.com
Sources
Related news
Kerala CM, Cleric Clash Over Muslim Women’s Public Role
Samastha Chief Backs Kanthapuram Amid Kerala Women Remarks Row
Kerala Chief Minister Satheesan Rejects Kanthapuram’s Restrictions on Women
IUML Defends Kanthapuram Remarks Amid Kerala Women’s Rights Row
Kerala Cleric’s Remarks on Women Draw Cross-Party Backlash
Congress Backs Satheesan Amid Debate Over Women’s Public Participation
Kanthapuram Urges Calm Amid Controversy Over Remarks on Women
