1 week ago
Supreme Court Declines to Reopen CBSE Class 12 Re-evaluation Portal
Some Class 12 students wanted CBSE to reopen its website for checking their exam marks.
They said the website crashed and stopped some students from applying on time.
Their petition also complained that some answer-sheet pages were missing, unclear or not checked.
CBSE said about 1.68 lakh students had successfully applied while the website was open.
The Supreme Court said the application window had been available to everyone for a set period.
Chief Justice Surya Kant said students who missed the opportunity could not receive a new chance through this petition.
The court did not rule that students could never have their answers re-evaluated.
It only refused to order CBSE to reopen the portal.
The Supreme Court declined to direct CBSE to reopen its Class 12 answer-sheet re-evaluation and verification portal.
The petitioner sought one additional week, saying a website crash prevented some students from applying for on-screen verification.
The court said the portal had been open to all candidates for a specified period and reopening it could trigger fresh claims.
CBSE said around 1.68 lakh students successfully applied during the notified window.
Students alleged that the On-Screen Marking system produced missing pages, illegible scans and unevaluated answers or pages.
- Who
- The Supreme Court, CBSE, the petitioner, and Class 12 students affected by the evaluation process were involved.
- What
- The Supreme Court declined to direct CBSE to reopen its portal for Class 12 answer-sheet re-evaluation and verification.
- Where
- The hearing took place before the Supreme Court in New Delhi.
- When
- The decision was reported on Tuesday, August 25; the year was not specified in the articles.
- Why
- The petitioner cited a website crash and problems with the On-Screen Marking system, while CBSE said the portal had been open to all candidates for a specified period.
Students and petitioner
CBSE and court position
Reopening the portal
Students and petitioner
The petitioner sought one more week, arguing that a website crash prevented some students from applying for verification.
CBSE and court position
The court said the portal had been open to everyone for a specified period and declined to order a fresh opportunity.
Reliability of On-Screen Marking
Students and petitioner
Students alleged that digital scanning and evaluation resulted in missing pages, illegible scans and unevaluated answers or pages.
CBSE and court position
CBSE defended the existing process in opposing the request to reopen the application window and pointed to the 1.68 lakh successful applications.
Effect of the ruling
Students and petitioner
Students who missed the deadline sought access to the re-evaluation and grievance process.
CBSE and court position
The court refused only to direct reopening through this plea; it did not state that students were categorically ineligible for re-evaluation.
Key facts
- Court decision
- The Supreme Court refused to direct CBSE to reopen the re-evaluation portal.
- Requested extension
- The petitioner asked for one additional week to apply for on-screen verification.
- CBSE applications
- CBSE said around 1.68 lakh students successfully applied during the notified window.
- Evaluation system
- Under On-Screen Marking, teachers assess scanned copies of physical answer sheets on computers.
- Student complaints
- The petition alleged missing scanned pages, illegible scans and answers or pages that were not evaluated.
- Court reasoning
- The bench said the window had been open to all candidates and reopening it could trigger fresh claims.
- Related proceedings
- Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said the Delhi High Court had dismissed a similar challenge.
- Broader scrutiny
- Education Minister Pralhad Joshi held a meeting to review CBSE’s academic, examination and administrative processes.
Quotes
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant
Chief Justice of India and member of the Supreme Court bench hearing the plea
“Why should we direct them to open this window again for you? If you don’t use the bus, you miss the bus. The window was open for everyone for a specified period.”
theprint.in
thehansindia.com
“If so many students managed to file applications, why did you not file it in time when the window was open?”
wionews.com
Sources
‘You missed the bus. It’s your bad luck’: India’s SC rejects plea to reopen CBSE Class 12 re-evaluation window. This is what we know
Supreme Court refuses reopening CBSE Class 12 re-evaluation portal, says ‘if you don’t use the bus, you miss it’
SC declines to direct reopening of CBSE re-evaluation portal for class 12 answer sheets
Supreme Court Refuses To Reopen CBSE Class 12 Re-Evaluation Portal
Related news
Supreme Court Rejects Plea To Reopen CBSE OSM Window
Supreme Court Seeks Centre Response on CBSE OSM Complaints
Centre Rejects Grace Marks Plea for CBSE Class 12 Students
SC to hear CBSE OSM exam plea on August 21
Supreme Court Seeks Centre Response on CBSE Answer Evaluation
CBSE Class 10 Re-evaluation, Marks Verification Window to Close Tomorrow
Subhash Chandra Challenges Five-Member NCLT Bench in Insolvency Case
Supreme Court Limits Manan Mishra’s Pro Tem BCI Role
Subhash Chandra Challenges Five-Member Bench in Insolvency Case
Subhash Chandra Challenges NCLT Bench as NCLAT Appeal Waits
NCLT halts Subhash Chandra asset sale amid lender challenge
