2 weeks ago
Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Plunges 5%; Brokerages Split on Outlook
Have you ever wanted to buy a toy, but some of your friends said it was a great idea while others said not to bother?
That is what is happening with a big car company in India called Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles.
Its shares, which are small pieces of ownership in the company, dropped by more than five percent recently.
Three smart money experts, called brokerages, looked at the company and gave three different opinions.
One expert, Motilal Oswal, says 'sell' because a part of the company called Jaguar Land Rover is having a hard time and the company owes more money.
Another expert, Nomura, says 'neutral', meaning it is neither a great buy nor a bad one.
The third expert, JM Financial, says 'add', because people in India are buying a lot of Tata cars.
Their ideas about how much the shares are worth are also very different.
The chairman of the big Tata group also said he will step down, which makes people wonder what will happen next.
In the end, nobody can say for sure what will happen, so people are told to think carefully before investing.
Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles (TMPV) shares plunged over 5% in early trade, trading around Rs 332.
Motilal Oswal issued a 'Sell' call with a Rs 310 target, Nomura a 'Neutral' with Rs 389, and JM Financial an 'Add' with Rs 375.
Q1 adjusted PAT came in at Rs 1,140 crore, far better than Motilal Oswal's estimated loss of Rs 120 crore.
Jaguar Land Rover continues to face demand and cost headwinds, and consolidated automotive debt rose to Rs 42,200 crore from Rs 30,700 crore.
Domestic passenger vehicle volumes jumped 46.3% year-on-year and revenue rose 66.2%, though margins are pressured by raw material inflation.
Tata Sons Chairman N Chandrasekaran decided not to seek reappointment beyond February 2027, putting the Group's succession plan in focus.
- Who
- Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles (TMPV), Tata Sons Chairman N Chandrasekaran, and brokerages Motilal Oswal, Nomura and JM Financial.
- What
- TMPV shares plunged over 5% in early trade after the company's Q1 results, with the three brokerages issuing split ratings: Sell, Neutral and Add.
- Where
- India, where Tata Group and its listed stocks are in focus.
- When
- In early trade on the day the article was published, following Q1 results; the stock is down about 9% so far in 2026.
- Why
- Concerns over Jaguar Land Rover's demand and cost headwinds and rising consolidated automotive debt, plus uncertainty over Tata Group succession after N Chandrasekaran opted not to seek reappointment beyond February 2027.
Bears (Motilal Oswal): Cautious, 'Sell'
Bulls (JM Financial): Constructive, 'Add'
Jaguar Land Rover outlook
Bears (Motilal Oswal): Cautious, 'Sell'
JLR continues to face multiple headwinds on the demand and cost fronts, and its cost-reduction initiative will only partially offset the pressure; rising debt is mostly due to JLR.
Bulls (JM Financial): Constructive, 'Add'
JLR's recovery efforts and cost-reduction measures could support the business, and Nomura even raised its average selling price assumptions for JLR.
Domestic growth vs group pressure
Bears (Motilal Oswal): Cautious, 'Sell'
Even after a better-than-expected Q1, the concerns around JLR and the higher debt keep the brokerage cautious on the stock.
Bulls (JM Financial): Constructive, 'Add'
Strong domestic performance (volumes up 46.3% YoY, revenue up 66.2%), electric vehicle demand and management's guidance for high double-digit FY27 volume growth justify an 'Add' call.
Valuation
Bears (Motilal Oswal): Cautious, 'Sell'
The stock trades nearly 21% below its 52-week high, and Motilal Oswal's target of Rs 310 implies about 7% downside from current levels.
Bulls (JM Financial): Constructive, 'Add'
At 3.8x FY28F EV/EBITDA, Nomura calls the valuation undemanding while factoring in risks; JM Financial's Rs 375 target implies about 13% upside.
Key facts
- Current share price
- Around Rs 332
- 52-week high
- Rs 419
- 52-week low
- Rs 294.30
- Q1 adjusted PAT
- Rs 1,140 crore (vs Motilal Oswal's estimated loss of Rs 120 crore)
- Consolidated automotive debt
- Rs 42,200 crore, up from Rs 30,700 crore in the previous quarter
- Domestic PV volume growth (YoY)
- 46.3%; revenue up 66.2%
- Brokerage ratings and targets
- Motilal Oswal: Sell/Rs 310; Nomura: Neutral/Rs 389; JM Financial: Add/Rs 375
- Stock performance in 2026
- Down about 9% so far in 2026
Quotes
Motilal Oswal analyst
Brokerage analyst for Motilal Oswal
“"The stock is trading at 3.8x FY28F EV/EBITDA, which we believe is undemanding, but is fair considering the risks."”
financialexpress.com
“"Management guided for high double‑digit domestic volume growth for FY27."”
financialexpress.com









