2 hrs ago
India Gains UNSC Backing, But Permanent Seat Remains Elusive
The United Nations Security Council helps deal with threats to peace around the world.
It has 15 members, including five permanent members with special veto powers.
India wants to become a permanent member because it is a large and influential country.
India also says the Council does not fairly represent today’s world, especially developing countries.
Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and the Czech Republic recently supported India’s request.
The United States, United Kingdom, France and Russia have also backed India.
China supports changing the Council but has not clearly supported India’s permanent seat.
Some countries want new permanent members to have no veto, but India disagrees.
Changing the Council would require a difficult amendment to the UN Charter.
Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and the Czech Republic backed India’s bid for a permanent UNSC seat.
India says the Council’s current structure does not reflect today’s geopolitical and economic realities.
The United States, United Kingdom, France and Russia support India’s permanent membership campaign.
China has supported broader UNSC reform but has not explicitly endorsed India’s permanent membership.
Reform requires amending the UN Charter, while disagreements remain over whether new permanent members should receive veto powers.
- Who
- India, supported by the Visegrad Group, the United States, the United Kingdom, France and Russia, is seeking permanent UNSC membership; China has not explicitly endorsed the bid.
- What
- India is campaigning for a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council while also seeking election as a non-permanent member for 2028–29.
- Where
- The endorsement was voiced at a Visegrad Group–India foreign ministers’ meeting in New York, on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly.
- When
- The latest endorsement came during the United Nations General Assembly, after India’s sustained campaign for UNSC reform.
- Why
- India says the current Council does not reflect contemporary geopolitical and economic realities and excludes the world’s most populous nation from permanent decision-making.
Supporters of India’s Permanent Seat
Obstacles and Reservations
Representation on the Council
Supporters of India’s Permanent Seat
India and its supporters argue that the Council should reflect current geopolitical and economic realities, including the importance of the Global South and India’s population and influence.
Obstacles and Reservations
The existing Council structure remains unchanged, and there is no vacant permanent seat under current rules.
Veto powers for New Members
Supporters of India’s Permanent Seat
India rejects a model in which new permanent members would lack veto rights, saying that would create a second tier of permanent membership and preserve the existing imbalance.
Obstacles and Reservations
The United States, France, Russia and the United Kingdom have indicated that new permanent members should forego veto powers.
China’s Position
Supporters of India’s Permanent Seat
India has received explicit support from four of the five permanent members and broader backing from several other countries.
Obstacles and Reservations
China has called for UNSC reform and referenced India’s aspiration to play a greater role, but has not explicitly endorsed India’s permanent membership in the same way as the other supporting permanent members.
Key facts
- UNSC membership
- The Security Council has 15 members: five permanent and 10 non-permanent.
- Permanent members
- The United States, United Kingdom, China, France and Russia hold permanent seats and veto powers.
- Latest supporters
- Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and the Czech Republic collectively backed India’s permanent membership.
- Other major supporters
- France, the United Kingdom, the United States and Russia have supported India’s bid.
- India’s UNSC record
- India has served eight times as a non-permanent member, most recently in 2021–22.
- Current campaign
- India has launched a campaign for a non-permanent seat for the 2028–29 term.
- Main barriers
- China has not explicitly endorsed India, and creating a new permanent seat requires amending the UN Charter.
Quotes
Xavier Bettel
Luxembourg’s Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister
“We all agree as V4 countries that India, as a part of the Global South, upcoming superpower in the Indo-Pacific region, must be at the table as the permanent member of the UN Security Council.”
firstpost.com
“If we say now, we need to have 10 members, because for me India belongs. It’s for sure. Look at the size of the country, the importance of your country. Why is India still not in?”
firstpost.com
Jeffrey Sachs
American economist and Columbia University professor
“India has the strongest claim and should absolutely be a member of the Security Council.”
firstpost.com
Sources
Related news
India Seeks Permanent UN Security Council Seat After Eight Terms
Visegrad Group Backs India’s Permanent UN Security Council Bid
Luxembourg Backs India’s Permanent Seat, Urges UN Veto Reform
BRICS Pushes Global South Representation Beyond Western Institutions
UN Backs Modi’s Push for Security Council Reform
Sridhar Vembu Urges India to Consider Leaving UN
Luxembourg’s Bettel Calls Tariff Wars Lose-Lose, Urges Cooperation
India and Luxembourg Highlight Growing Ties Amid Global Crisis
Luxembourg Foreign Minister Praises India's Efficient Political Leadership
