2 weeks ago
Batwara 1947 review: Partition film too safe and staid
Batwara 1947 is a movie about a very sad and scary time in history called Partition, when India and Pakistan were being separated into two countries.
The movie follows a family: a father named Sikandar, a mother named Hamida, and their daughter Tanno.
They live in a city called Meerut, but angry people are coming, so they decide to run away to another city called Lahore.
While they are trying to leave, a big crowd attacks their train at the station.
In all the chaos, the family's son, Javed, is left behind.
The movie also shows terrible things happening to other families, like a group setting a Hindu family on fire.
A movie reviewer watched this film and wrote about how it made them feel.
The reviewer thinks the movie is okay but not bold or powerful enough.
They are upset that the film tries too hard to show both sides being equally bad, and they wish it would speak more strongly to today's world.
Batwara 1947 is a Hindi Partition drama starring Sunny Deol, Preity Zinta, Karan Deol, and Khushi Hajare.
Businessman Sikandar Mirza, his wife Hamida, and daughter Tanno flee their Meerut home for Lahore as Hindu rioters close in.
A mob attacks the family's train at the station, and their son Javed is left behind in the chaos.
The film shows the mirror image of a Muslim mob burning a Hindu family alive and Pakistani rioters boasting about their brutality.
The review calls the film "too safe and staid to speak to the times," criticizing it as sanctimonious in its balance of inhumanity on both sides.
- Who
- Businessman Sikandar Mirza (played by Sunny Deol), his wife Hamida (Preity Zinta), daughter Tanno (Khushi Hajare), and son Javed (Karan Deol); the film is reviewed by the article's critic.
- What
- A film review criticizes Partition drama Batwara 1947 as too safe and staid, complaining it sanctimoniously balances inhumanity on both sides.
- Where
- The film opens in Meerut, India, with the family fleeing to Lahore.
- When
- The review's publication date is not stated; the film is set in the days leading up to and just after India's independence in 1947.
- Why
- The reviewer argues the film is sanctimonious about its equal distribution of brutality across religions and fails to speak to the times.
Key facts
- Film
- Batwara 1947
- Lead actors
- Sunny Deol, Preity Zinta, Karan Deol, Khushi Hajare
- Setting
- India in the days leading up to and just after independence in 1947
- Central characters
- Businessman Sikandar Mirza, wife Hamida, daughter Tanno, son Javed
- Opening situation
- Family flees Meerut for Lahore as Hindu rioters close in
- Key plot event
- Mob attacks the family's train; son Javed is left behind
- Reviewer's verdict
- Too safe and staid to speak to the times; sanctimonious equal balance of inhumanity










