1 hr ago
Congress Remarks on Retired Officers Draw Veteran Backlash
Congress spokesperson Reetam Singh said retired Army officers should avoid television, politics and news discussions.
Singh argued that retired officers’ public influence could threaten civilian control and compared the risk to coups in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Southeast Asia.
Military veterans said retirees remain citizens with constitutional rights to speak, vote, contest elections and participate in democracy.
Maj Gen Harsha Kakar, Lt Gen P.R. Shankar and Col Rohit Dev criticised Singh’s remarks and questioned his understanding and respect for the armed forces.
The dispute began after Singh responded to comments by Maj Gen Kakar concerning CJP spokesperson Saurav Dass.
- Who
- Congress spokesperson Reetam Singh and retired military officers including Maj Gen Harsha Kakar, Lt Gen P.R. Shankar and Col Rohit Dev.
- What
- A dispute over whether retired Army personnel should participate in television debates, politics and public commentary.
- Where
- India, in public statements and posts on X.
- When
- The veterans’ responses and criticism were reported on Monday; the dispute followed Singh’s earlier posts.
- Why
- Singh said retired officers should avoid civilian politics to protect civilian control, while veterans said retirement does not remove their constitutional rights.
Reetam Singh’s position
Veterans’ position
Participation in public life
Reetam Singh’s position
Retired Army officers should avoid television, politics and news discussions, and should not dictate how civilian leaders make decisions.
Veterans’ position
Veterans remain citizens after service and retain the freedom to express opinions, vote, contest elections and participate in democratic discourse.
Risk to civilian authority
Reetam Singh’s position
Singh said unrestricted political involvement by retired officers could contribute to a military coup and should be restricted after retirement.
Veterans’ position
The veterans rejected the implication that their public comments threaten civilian control, saying India’s system keeps serving armed forces personnel under civilian authority.
Tone and respect
Reetam Singh’s position
Singh said retired officers should remember that their military role was to follow orders from civilian leadership.
Veterans’ position
The veterans said Singh’s language was insulting, showed limited understanding and reflected disrespect toward the armed forces.
Key facts
- Congress spokesperson
- Reetam Singh
- Veterans named
- Maj Gen Harsha Kakar, Lt Gen P.R. Shankar and Col Rohit Dev
- Main criticism
- Singh said retired Army officers should stay away from television, politics and news discussions.
- Veterans’ position
- Retired service members retain the rights to express views, vote, contest elections and participate in democracy.
- Civilian control concern
- Singh argued that retired officers’ influence could create risks similar to military coups in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Southeast Asia.
- Trigger for dispute
- Singh was responding to remarks by Maj Gen Kakar concerning CJP spokesperson Saurav Dass.
Quotes
Major General Harsha Kakar
Retired Indian Army major general and veteran critic of Singh
“I seriously wonder how Congress nominated a person like Reetam Singh as a spokesperson. His knowledge is not only shallow but his thinking illogical. I have earned my rank and dues from service to the nation in conditions you would never have dreamt about. Don't be jealous.”
thehansindia.com
“Veterans are Citizens of Bharat who Vote too and have a definite say in Democracy of Bharat. They pay their Taxes in Advance as well, just like when they were serving in uniform. They have Freedom to Express, Right to Vote, Fight Elections, etc too.”
thehansindia.com
Sources
Related news
BJP Attacks Congress Over Veteran’s Ram Temple CEO Appointment
Revanth Reddy’s Controversial Remarks Threaten Congress in Telangana
Ravi Shankar Prasad calls Chidambaram's 'mentally Naxal' remark irresponsible
Amarinder Singh Remarks Fuel Speculation About Possible Congress Return
Army Veterans Criticize Viral Video of Ladakh Checkpoint Outburst
Naxal violence victims condemn Chidambaram's 'dimaagi Naxal' remark
Bangladesh Dengue Outbreak Intensifies as Hospitals Face Record Daily Admissions
Mushtaq Ahmed Fears Working For Mohsin Naqvi's PCB
Hili Land Port Exports Resume After Six-Day Deadlock
Twenty-Three Suspected Bangladeshi Infiltrators Sent to Chhattisgarh Detention Centre
