3 weeks ago
Lok Sabha standoff over police action on student protesters
Some students in Delhi were protesting, and the opposition party says the police may have used guns against them.
Rahul Gandhi, an opposition leader, wants the Home Minister, Amit Shah, to answer one simple question: did he tell the police to do this?
The government says Amit Shah is ready to talk about it in Parliament and answer all questions.
But Rahul Gandhi says a general speech is not enough — he wants a clear yes or no to that one question.
The government's leaders say Rahul Gandhi is stopping Parliament from doing its work.
They say he keeps changing what he wants so the argument never ends.
A government MP even said a businessman named George Soros ordered Rahul Gandhi to keep changing the rules.
The government also says no bullets were fired at the protest spot, which is called Jantar Mantar.
Rahul Gandhi says he was told pellet guns were fired at the students.
Because the two sides cannot agree, the big meeting of Parliament stays blocked while they argue about how to discuss the issue.
BJP MP Nishikant Dubey and Union Minister J.P. Nadda accused Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi of 'changing the goalpost' and deliberately obstructing the Lok Sabha.
The government said it had agreed to a detailed discussion and that Home Minister Amit Shah was ready to respond to every point raised by the Opposition.
Gandhi demanded a categorical answer on who authorised the alleged firing on protesting students in Delhi, insisting Shah answer one specific question.
Nadda rejected Gandhi's claim, saying that according to the government's position no bullets were fired at Jantar Mantar.
Gandhi, speaking alongside Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, rejected the proposed debate as a 'fantasy conversation' and said the central question must be answered directly.
- Who
- Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi and Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on one side; Home Minister Amit Shah, Union Minister J.P. Nadda, BJP MP Nishikant Dubey, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju and Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla on the other.
- What
- A confrontation over whether a parliamentary discussion must include a categorical answer on who authorised alleged police firing against protesting students, with the Opposition blocking the Lok Sabha until it gets a direct response.
- Where
- New Delhi, in the Lok Sabha (the lower house of India's Parliament).
- When
- Monday
- Why
- Gandhi alleges pellet guns were fired at students protesting in Delhi and wants accountability for who authorised the action; the government says Amit Shah is ready to answer in a debate and accuses Gandhi of obstructing the House.
Opposition (Congress-led)
Government (BJP)
Parliamentary discussion vs direct answer
Opposition (Congress-led)
The Opposition will not settle for a general speech; it wants a categorical answer on who authorised the alleged police action before allowing the Lok Sabha to proceed.
Government (BJP)
The government has agreed to a full discussion and says the Home Minister will respond to every point; Gandhi keeps changing his demand and is deliberately obstructing the House.
Alleged police firing on students
Opposition (Congress-led)
Gandhi alleges pellet guns were fired at students protesting in Delhi and demands to know who authorised it.
Government (BJP)
Nadda rejects the claim, saying the government's position is that no bullets were fired at Jantar Mantar, and challenges the premise of the firing allegation.
Motive behind the obstruction
Opposition (Congress-led)
Gandhi says the Opposition is seeking accountability on a specific question and rejects the proposed debate as a 'fantasy conversation'.
Government (BJP)
Nishikant Dubey claims the 'order to change the goalpost' was given to Gandhi by George Soros, and Nadda says Gandhi is creating an atmosphere of anarchy.
Key facts
- Location
- New Delhi; Lok Sabha
- Core dispute
- Who authorised the alleged firing on protesting students — a question the Opposition wants answered directly before any discussion
- Opposition demand
- Categorical answer from Home Minister Amit Shah on whether he authorised the alleged police action
- Government position
- Amit Shah ready to respond to all Opposition points in a detailed discussion; no bullets were fired at Jantar Mantar
- Accusation against Gandhi
- BJP says Rahul Gandhi is 'changing the goalpost' and deliberately obstructing the Lok Sabha
- Key figures
- Rahul Gandhi, Mallikarjun Kharge, Amit Shah, J.P. Nadda, Nishikant Dubey, Kiren Rijiju, Om Birla
Quotes
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju
Indian government minister
“The order to change the goalpost was given to Rahul Gandhi by George Soros.”
thehansindia.com
“The Home Minister will answer the Opposition on every point raised.”
thehansindia.com










