1 hr ago
Supreme Court Cancels Bail Over Assault on Hospital Doctors
India’s Supreme Court cancelled the bail of four people accused of attacking and abusing doctors.
The alleged attack happened at a municipal hospital in Dombivli, Maharashtra.
The court said doctors need to feel safe so they can make careful decisions for patients.
It said violence and threats cannot be used to complain about medical treatment.
The court also said elected representatives must use legal institutions instead of fear or personal influence.
The four accused must surrender to the trial court by October 5.
Doctors and hospital workers who may testify must be protected from threats.
The court also asked Maharashtra to consider whether preventive-detention laws should be used.
The Supreme Court cancelled bail granted to Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre and three associates accused of assaulting and abusing doctors.
The incident occurred on July 6 at Shastri Nagar Municipal Hospital in Dombivli, Maharashtra.
The court said doctors cannot exercise sound, independent judgment while facing violence, intimidation or coercion.
The accused were ordered to surrender before the trial court by October 5, while material witnesses must receive protection.
The bench cited Mhatre’s reported criminal history and directed Maharashtra to examine whether preventive-detention laws apply.
- Who
- The Supreme Court, Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre, three associates, and doctors and hospital staff involved in the case.
- What
- The court cancelled bail for four accused in an alleged assault and verbal-abuse case involving three doctors.
- Where
- Shastri Nagar Municipal Hospital in Dombivli, Maharashtra; proceedings were considered by the Supreme Court in New Delhi.
- When
- The alleged assault occurred on July 6; the Supreme Court’s detailed order was reported on October 1.
- Why
- The court said threats against medical professionals undermine their ability to work safely and noted concerns about the accused’s conduct and criminal antecedents.
Key facts
- Accused
- Ramesh Mhatre, Ramesh Laxman Pawar, Pramod alias Prakash Uddhav Nikam, and Akshay Sharad Karande
- Alleged victims
- Three doctors, including a woman doctor, who were on duty in the labour ward
- Incident date
- July 6
- Location
- Shastri Nagar Municipal Hospital, Dombivli, Maharashtra
- Surrender deadline
- October 5
- Witness protection
- The trial court was directed to protect material witnesses under the Maharashtra Witness Protection and Security Act, 2017
- Reported criminal cases against Mhatre
- Eighteen cases, including cases involving offences punishable under Sections 302 and 307 of the Indian Penal Code
Quotes
Supreme Court of India
The Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta
“A doctor cannot reasonably be expected to exercise sound and independent judgment while labouring under the apprehension of physical violence, intimidation or coercion. The safety and dignity of the medical professional are consequently not matters of personal privilege. They are the safeguards which serve the larger public interest in ensuring that medical care is rendered with the concentration, composure and judgment that the profession demands,he/she cannot supplant those institutions by”
theprint.in
Sources
Related news
Supreme Court Cancels Sena Corporator’s Bail in Thane Assault Case
Supreme Court Flags Maharashtra Doctor Attacks, Reviews Mhatre Bail
Supreme Court Cancels Bail, Orders Corporator Back to Jail
Supreme Court Warns Elected Leaders Against Attacking Doctors
Maharashtra government challenges Sena corporator’s bail in doctors’ assault case
Supreme Court Toughens Response as Sena Corporator Drops Bail Plea
Madhya Pradesh High Court Reconsiders OBC Creamy Layer Application
Supreme Court Says CBDT Circulars Cannot Override Income Tax Act
Debate Over Ballot Papers, EVMs and Election Trust Continues
