Health · Healthcare & Policy · 1 hr ago
Readers weigh in on medical training, health costs and AI isolation
STAT published selected letters responding to three essays about medical education, U.S. health care costs and AI chatbots.
A Harvard medical student argues medical students need patient contact before Step 1, saying those encounters help them learn to care for people, not just prepare for an exam.
The original proposal was to begin medical school after students take Step 1, a licensing exam.
A physician says administrative complexity adds to health care costs and urges insurers to standardize billing, preauthorization and policy options.
The third letter warns that chatbots could gradually replace people a user once confided in, even if individual conversations seem responsible.
It supports independent researchers getting access to platform data to study whether chatbot use contributes to isolation, including among adolescents.
The text provides no further details about what happens next.
STAT published selected letters responding to three essays on medical training, U.S. health care costs and AI use.
Harvard Medical School student Surya Pulukuri argued that early patient contact helps medical students develop compassion and should not wait until after Step 1.
Edward Hoffer said private insurers contribute to health care administrative costs and called for simpler billing and pre-authorization rules.
A third letter supported giving independent researchers access to AI platform data to study whether chatbot use contributes to isolation.
STAT said its letters aim to encourage good-faith discussion of issues raised in First Opinion essays.
- Who
- STAT published letters from Surya Pulukuri, Edward Hoffer and a writer responding to an essay on AI and isolation.
- What
- The letters addressed medical training, U.S. health care costs and research into AI use and isolation.
- When
- STAT published the article on Nov. 21, 2026.
- Where
- The letters appeared on STAT’s First Opinion platform.
- Why
- STAT said it publishes selected letters to encourage robust, good-faith discussion of issues raised in First Opinion essays.
Proponents of starting medical school after Step 1
Surya Pulukuri
Early clinical exposure
Proponents of starting medical school after Step 1
The proposal by Rachel E. Fabi and Amy Caruso Brown would start medical school after students take Step 1.
Surya Pulukuri
Pulukuri said early patient contact helps students learn to become physicians and should not be postponed.
This story does not have a timeline yet.
- Publication date
- Nov. 21, 2026
- Medical training proposal
- Start medical school after students take Step 1
- Medical training letter writer
- Surya Pulukuri, Harvard Medical School student
- Health care letter writer
- Edward Hoffer, Harvard Medical School
- Administrative costs
- Some 25% of U.S. “health care” spending
What people are saying
A flashcard can teach a student what causes a miscarriage. It takes a patient to teach what it means to grieve one.
Some 25% of U.S. “health care” spending goes to administrative costs.