Politics · Mexico · 1 hr ago
Retired Mexican judge asks for public hearing in disciplinary case
Retired judge Martha Eugenia Magaña López has asked Mexico’s Judicial Discipline Tribunal for a public hearing in the administrative case against her.
The case concerns an injunction she granted against former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s judicial reform.
Magaña wants the hearing to be open in person or broadcast live, with only unrelated personal or confidential information kept private.
She argues that the Constitution gives her the right to be judged in public, even though the tribunal’s rules provide for private sessions.
She says the public should hear her defense and the tribunal’s reasoning, as well as how its members vote.
She has formally asked the tribunal’s full membership to grant her request, but no decision on it is reported.
Retired Mexican judge Martha Eugenia Magaña López has asked the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal to hear her disciplinary case in public.
The case concerns her decision to grant an injunction against former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador’s judicial reform.
Magaña requested an in-person hearing or a live broadcast through the tribunal’s official channels.
She said the public should be able to hear her defence, the disciplinary commission’s arguments and the vote.
- Who
- Retired judge Martha Eugenia Magaña López asked the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal to hold a public hearing.
- What
- She requested that her disciplinary case be discussed and decided in public.
- When
- The request was reported on November 18, 2026. The date it was submitted is not stated.
- Where
- Mexico.
- Why
- Magaña said the public has a right to hear her defence and that proceedings should be transparent.
This story does not have two clearly opposing sides.
Magaña granted an injunction against the judicial reform of former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador.
El Universal reported that Magaña had asked the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal to hold a public hearing in her disciplinary case.
- Judge
- Martha Eugenia Magaña López
- Tribunal
- Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal
- Case
- Administrative disciplinary proceeding over an injunction against the judicial reform
- Hearing request
- In-person access or a live broadcast through official channels
- Published
- November 18, 2026
What people are saying
Mexican society demands a transparent and open-door exercise of justice. The debate about the exercise of judicial functions and the defence of judicial independence must take place before the public.
The Mexican people have the right to know directly the arguments of my defence, the reasons given by the members of the Judicial Disciplinary Commission and the outcome of the vote.