Politics · Australia · 12 hrs ago
Victorian Greens seek court order over independent candidate’s voting cards
The Victorian Greens are seeking an urgent court order to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan distributing how-to-vote cards in Prahran, Melbourne.
The party says Finnigan’s first cards copied its colours, font and logo, but directed voters to rank Finnigan first and the Liberals fourth.
Finnigan agreed to change the cards, but the Greens said the revisions did not resolve their concerns and filed papers in the Victorian Supreme Court.
The dispute matters because the Greens are trying to win back the ultra-marginal Prahran seat, which they lost to the Liberals in a February 2025 byelection by 1.3 percentage points.
The Greens alleged Finnigan’s campaign team also wore similar green shirts and stood beside Greens volunteers; Finnigan said the changes had been made quickly and denied instructing campaigners to stand there.
A judge said the original card looked like a deliberate attempt to pass Finnigan off as a Greens candidate, but adjourned the case until Saturday to hear evidence from the Victorian Electoral Commission, which accepted the revised card for online publication.
The Victorian Greens have asked the Supreme Court for an urgent order to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan distributing how-to-vote cards.
The party says Finnigan’s original cards and campaign presentation closely mimicked Greens branding while directing voters to preference the Liberals fourth.
Finnigan changed the card after the Greens threatened legal action, but the party said the changes did not resolve its concerns.
The court adjourned the matter until 3pm on Saturday to hear testimony from the Victorian Election Commission.
The commission accepted Finnigan’s subsequent card and published it online on Friday evening.
- Who
- The Victorian Greens and independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan.
- What
- The Greens are seeking a court order to stop Finnigan distributing how-to-vote cards they say mimic the party’s branding.
- When
- The Greens lodged court papers on Friday afternoon. Finnigan’s campaign had distributed the original card during prepoll on Wednesday.
- Where
- Prahran, Victoria, Australia.
- Why
- The Greens say voters were deliberately misled by the card’s branding and preference recommendations. Finnigan says they changed the card and denies instructing campaign workers to stand next to Greens volunteers.
Victorian Greens
Tosh-Jake Finnigan
Campaign material
Victorian Greens
The Greens allege the card and campaign presentation closely mimicked their branding and misled voters.
Tosh-Jake Finnigan
Finnigan says they changed the card after the Greens’ request and chose the green colour because it is called Irish green and they have Irish background.
Campaigning at prepoll
Victorian Greens
The Greens allege Finnigan’s team stood near Greens volunteers and placards.
Tosh-Jake Finnigan
Finnigan says their campaign team had not been instructed to stand next to the Greens.
Finnigan’s campaign handed out how-to-vote cards at prepoll using the Greens’ colour scheme, font and triangle logo.
Greens state director Martin Shield asked Finnigan to stop distributing the material and threatened legal action.
Finnigan produced an amended card with different colours and a revised banner.
The Greens’ lawyers lodged papers in the Supreme Court.
The Victorian Election Commission accepted Finnigan’s subsequent card and published it online; Justice John Watson adjourned the matter until 3pm on Saturday.
- Candidate
- Tosh-Jake Finnigan
- Court
- Supreme Court of Victoria
- Electoral area
- Prahran
- Original card banner
- Vote 1 Green Values
- Amended card banner
- Vote 1 Trans Greens Values
- Court hearing
- Adjourned until 3pm on Saturday
What people are saying
There is no other reason for an independent candidate who has an infinite range of colours and styles to choose from to so closely mimic the Greens, including the way people paid to hand out were dressed and where they were directed to stand.
It is my belief that they don’t want me to hand out on Saturday, which will be one of the busiest days of prepoll
I am someone who holds Greens values, of course I am going to have some kind of green shirt
looked like a pretty deliberate attempt to pass yourself off as a Greens candidate