Science & Tech · Science & Environment · 2 hrs ago
Simulations suggest comets rarely delivered life’s ingredients to early Earth
A Cambridge-led team simulated comet impacts on early Earth to test whether comets could have supplied ingredients for life.
Comets contain hydrogen cyanide, a chemical that laboratory experiments can turn into building blocks of DNA, RNA, sugars and fats.
But the heat and force of impacts destroy most of these molecules, while Earth’s atmosphere can break up smaller comets before they reach the ground.
The researchers ran 100,000 simulations of Earth’s first 500 million years, varying comet sizes, speeds and impact angles.
The typical simulation had no successful delivery, even though the team chose assumptions that favored comets.
A successful impact had to land on exposed land and leave enough hydrogen cyanide intact, and most runs had none.
The results make comets an unlikely source of life’s ingredients, though the study is a model, not a measurement.
New simulations suggest comets rarely delivered useful amounts of life’s chemical ingredients to early Earth.
The team replayed Earth’s first 500 million years in 100,000 computer simulations.
In 54% of the runs, no comet delivered enough hydrogen cyanide to count as a success.
The researchers say atmospheric breakup, impact heat and limited exposed land made delivery difficult.
- Who
- Richard Anslow of the University of Cambridge’s Institute of Astronomy led the research with colleagues at Cambridge and the University of Edinburgh.
- What
- Simulations found that comets rarely delivered a useful dose of hydrogen cyanide to early Earth.
- When
- The simulations covered Earth’s first 500 million years.
- Where
- Earth.
- Why
- Comet impacts often destroyed the molecules, and a successful delivery also required exposed land.
This story does not have two clearly opposing sides.
The simulations modeled comet bombardment across this period.
Successful deliveries in the simulations most often occurred around this time.
Other researchers place the last common ancestor of all living things around this time.
- Simulation runs
- 100,000
- Runs with no successful delivery
- 54%
- Comets per run
- More than 100,000 struck Earth in each run
- Hydrogen cyanide in comet water ice
- About one-tenth of a percent
- Small-comet threshold
- Comets smaller than about 330 feet (100 meters) across explode high in the atmosphere
What people are saying
It’s kind of a romantic idea, but our results suggest it’s highly unlikely
It was a surprise how strongly our simulations – building on recent advances in the modeling of cometary impacts – disfavored this long-standing hypothesis in origins of life research, finding in most cases no comets delivering sufficient feedstock molecules for the origins of life