Health · Healthcare & Policy · 8 hrs ago
Naples court upholds order to provide man with specialized wheelchair
A Naples appeals court upheld an order for a specialized powered wheelchair for Christian Durso, a 35-year-old from Capri with spinal muscular atrophy.
The local health authority had denied him a replacement for about a year and a half, saying the prescribed chair was too costly.
His old wheelchair was no longer made and could not be repaired because replacement parts were unavailable.
Specialists said he needed functions including powered tilting, reclining, seat elevation and standing support.
The court said the authority had not identified a suitable alternative or shown that its spending limit could buy a device meeting his needs.
The ruling says access to suitable medical equipment cannot depend only on a spending cap, and may guide other cases involving disability support.
The health authority’s appeal was rejected, leaving in place the original order to provide the wheelchair.
The Naples Court of Appeal rejected the appeal by local health authority ASL Napoli 1 Centro and upheld an order to provide Christian Durso with a specialized powered wheelchair.
The ruling, dated 10 November, confirms the first-instance judgment requiring the authority to provide the wheelchair in full.
Durso, a 35-year-old from Capri with spinal muscular atrophy, had gone about a year and a half without a replacement for his old wheelchair.
The old chair was no longer in production and could not be repaired because spare parts were unavailable.
The court said the authority had not identified a suitable alternative device for his needs.
- Who
- Christian Durso, a 35-year-old from Capri, and ASL Napoli 1 Centro, the local health authority.
- What
- The Naples Court of Appeal rejected the authority’s appeal and upheld an order to provide Durso with a specialized powered wheelchair.
- When
- The court issued its ruling on 10 November. The article was published on 19 November 2026.
- Where
- Naples, Italy; Durso is from Capri.
- Why
- His old wheelchair was no longer in production and could not be repaired, and the prescribed replacement had features required for his condition. The authority had not shown that a lower-cost option would meet his needs.
ASL Napoli 1 Centro
Christian Durso
Funding and wheelchair provision
ASL Napoli 1 Centro
The authority appealed the order to provide the prescribed wheelchair; the article says it had treated some required features as optional.
Christian Durso
Durso sought a wheelchair with functions prescribed by specialists to meet his needs.
Suitable alternative
ASL Napoli 1 Centro
The authority raised objections but did not identify a concrete alternative the court considered suitable.
Christian Durso
Durso argued that the prescribed wheelchair was essential to his autonomy and dignity.
ASL Napoli 1 Centro denied Durso a replacement for his old wheelchair.
The Naples Court of Appeal rejected the health authority’s appeal and upheld the first-instance order.
Il Fatto Quotidiano published its report on the ruling.
- Person
- Christian Durso, 35, from Capri
- Health authority
- ASL Napoli 1 Centro
- Court ruling
- 10 November
- Wheelchair
- Powered, with tilt, reclining up to 180 degrees, elevation and three-stage standing functions
- Period without replacement
- About a year and a half
What people are saying
This ruling can set a precedent because it affirms a fundamental principle: the right to an appropriate aid cannot be subject to a spending cap.
A clear victory not only for me, but also fundamental for everyone living in conditions similar to mine.
The health authority could have authorized the wheelchair immediately and pursued its appeals, showing at least a minimum of humanity toward someone living with a severe disability and an evident need, but it chose another path. It lost.