Politics · Australia · 4 hrs ago
Experts criticise Victorian plans to detain more young offenders
In Victoria, Labor and the Coalition have proposed tougher detention for young offenders ahead of the state election.
Liberal leader Jess Wilson has proposed $60 million for prison boot camps, while Premier Ben Carroll has pledged $204 million for a system that could detain young people for up to 12 months.
The proposals come after youth crime became a major political issue, with offending rates among 12- to 17-year-olds rising 24 per cent from 2019 to 2025, then falling 9.6 per cent last year.
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts say detention for low-level offences will not address the causes of offending.
They say a proposal developed by magistrate Jennifer Bowles would instead make rehabilitation orders based on clinical need, not criminal offending.
It would place young people in homely treatment units for up to six months, followed by 12 months of intensive community care.
Experts say this health-focused approach could help young people with severe substance abuse and related risks, but the sources do not say whether the government will change its plan.
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts have criticised Labor and Coalition plans to detain more young people for low-level offences.
They say detention will not address the causes of youth offending and differs from a proposed health and welfare approach to rehabilitation.
Labor has proposed detention sentences of up to 12 months for offences including theft, vandalism and minor assaults.
The Coalition has pledged $60 million for prison “boot camps” for repeat low-level youth offenders.
Crime rates among children aged 12 to 17 rose 24 per cent between 2019 and 2025, then fell 9.6 per cent last year.
- Who
- Victorian Labor and Coalition leaders have proposed detention measures; youth justice and drug and alcohol experts have criticised them.
- What
- Labor proposed youth rehabilitation detention of up to 12 months, while the Coalition announced a $60 million plan for boot camps.
- When
- The article was published on November 18, 2026. The Coalition announcement was made on Sunday.
- Where
- Victoria, Australia.
- Why
- The parties say their plans respond to youth offending. Experts say detention will not address the underlying causes.
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts
Victorian Labor and the Coalition
Approach
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts
Experts favour non-punitive rehabilitation based on clinical need.
Victorian Labor and the Coalition
Labor proposes detention at sentencing, and the Coalition proposes prison boot camps.
Purpose
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts
Experts say treatment should address substance abuse and other underlying needs.
Victorian Labor and the Coalition
Labor says its plan aims to treat issues driving harmful behaviour; the Coalition says its camps will teach discipline.
Placement and duration
Youth justice and drug and alcohol experts
Bowles’ proposal envisages homely units for up to six months, followed by 12 months of intensive community care.
Victorian Labor and the Coalition
Labor’s detention sentences could last up to 12 months and include placement at Malmsbury; the Coalition proposed boot camps but the article gives no duration.
Magistrate Jennifer Bowles published a study of programs in Sweden, England, Scotland and New Zealand.
Labor reopened the Malmsbury Youth Justice Centre to hold young offenders on remand.
Liberal leader Jess Wilson announced a $60 million plan for prison boot camps.
Premier Ben Carroll announced a plan to spend $204 million over two years on youth rehabilitation detention.
The SMH article reported experts’ criticism of the plans.
- Labor proposal
- $204 million over two years
- Labor detention term
- Up to 12 months
- Coalition plan
- $60 million for prison boot camps
- Bowles proposal
- Homely units for up to six months, followed by 12 months of intensive community care
- Youth offending rates
- Rose 24 per cent from 2019 to 2025
- Last year
- Offending rates fell 9.6 per cent
What people are saying
We’re trying to look at an option which is going to break that cycle for young people and give them a chance to actually treat the underlying issues and symptoms that are driving their involvement in unsafe and harmful behaviours,