Politics · Germany · 3 hrs ago
German party leaders clash over plans to socialise private housing
Left Party leader Ines Schwerdtner and CSU general secretary Martin Huber clashed on German TV over plans to bring private housing under public ownership.
The debate took place on Maischberger, a programme that was supposed to focus on the federal budget.
The dispute centred on Berlin's proposal to socialise private housing, meaning a change in who owns the properties.
Huber argued that the policy would not create homes and would cost too much, comparing the Left Party to Fidel Castro and Erich Honecker.
Schwerdtner said some rents would fall, but she could not guarantee lower rents for everyone.
She said rent increases in public and socialised homes would be capped at two percent a year, and that the policy would prevent illegally excessive rents.
The argument reflects a wider clash over housing costs and ownership as Berlin considers a left-led government.
Left Party leader Ines Schwerdtner and CSU Secretary-General Martin Huber clashed over plans to socialise private housing during a television debate.
Schwerdtner said the policy would change ownership structures, rule out unlawfully excessive rents and lower rents for some tenants.
Huber argued that socialising housing would create no homes and called it a socialist “suicide mission”.
The debate also covered the federal budget, migration and Berlin politics.
Schwerdtner said rent cuts could not be guaranteed, while annual rent increases for affected and state-owned homes would be capped at 2%.
- Who
- Left Party leader Ines Schwerdtner and CSU Secretary-General Martin Huber.
- What
- They disputed plans to socialise private housing and also discussed the budget, migration and Berlin politics.
- When
- Tuesday evening; the article was published on 18 November 2026.
- Where
- On the television programme Maischberger.
- Why
- They disagreed over the effects of socialising private housing, including whether it would lower rents or create homes.
Ines Schwerdtner
Martin Huber
Effect of socialising housing
Ines Schwerdtner
It would change ownership structures, exclude unlawfully excessive rents in future and lower rents for affected tenants.
Martin Huber
It would create no homes and involve enormous costs.
Rent reductions
Ines Schwerdtner
Some rents would fall, but rent cuts could not be guaranteed; annual increases for affected and state-owned homes would be capped at 2%.
Martin Huber
He opposed the plan, describing socialisation as a socialist “suicide mission”.
Schwerdtner acknowledged that she could not guarantee rent cuts following socialisation.
The Left Party parliamentary group board in Berlin requested the exclusion of disputed MP Vanessa Emde.
Schwerdtner and Huber debated socialising private housing on Maischberger.
- Participants
- Ines Schwerdtner and Martin Huber
- Programme
- Maischberger
- Rent cap
- 2% annual increases for state-owned and socialised homes
- Berlin MP
- Vanessa Emde
- Publication date
- 18 November 2026
1 source
What people are saying
a mixture of Fidel Castro and Erich Honecker
Anyone who has no right to stay must leave the country.
Some rents will fall.
You suspended the debt brake for rearmament, but there is a shortage everywhere in education, on the railways and in infrastructure.