Politics · France · 16 hrs ago
Isabelle Saporta and Prisca Thévenot clash in heated LCI debate
Isabelle Saporta and Prisca Thévenot clashed on French TV channel LCI during a debate about social unrest and protests.
Saporta, a journalist and commentator, criticised the record of governments led by President Emmanuel Macron, in power for about a decade.
Thévenot, a former government spokesperson, defended their actions and cited crisis measures including the “whatever it takes” economic support programme.
The argument turned personal, with interruptions and accusations as the two disputed the response to student protests and violence at demonstrations.
Thévenot said Saporta should get involved in politics and put forward proposals, while Saporta said she had heard the same answers before.
Saporta stopped listening to Thévenot, checking her phone and saying the answers did not interest her.
The exchange drew sharply divided reactions online, with some supporting Saporta’s criticism and others condemning her behaviour.
Isabelle Saporta and Prisca Thévenot clashed during a heated debate on LCI about social unrest, protests and the record of Emmanuel Macron’s governments.
Saporta accused the former government spokesperson of belonging to a majority that had put France “on its knees” over the past decade.
Thévenot defended her camp’s actions and urged Saporta to take political responsibility and make proposals.
The exchange escalated as they interrupted each other, and Saporta said she was not interested in hearing Thévenot’s repeated arguments.
The debate took place on Éric Brunet’s LCI programme on 19 October 2026.
- Who
- Journalist Isabelle Saporta and former government spokesperson Prisca Thévenot.
- What
- They clashed in a televised debate over social unrest, protests and the record of Emmanuel Macron’s governments.
- When
- 19 October 2026.
- Where
- On LCI, in Éric Brunet’s programme Brunet sans filtre.
- Why
- They disagreed over the government’s response to protests and violence, and over the record of Macron’s majority.
Isabelle Saporta
Prisca Thévenot
Government record
Isabelle Saporta
Saporta said Macron’s majority had put the country “on its knees” and continued to lecture others despite its record.
Prisca Thévenot
Thévenot defended the actions of successive Macron governments, including economic support measures during earlier crises.
Political responsibility
Isabelle Saporta
Saporta argued that the government had failed to provide answers to the ongoing student movement.
Prisca Thévenot
Thévenot urged Saporta to get involved in politics and make proposals rather than only criticising from a television studio.
Protests and violence
Isabelle Saporta
Saporta rejected Thévenot’s arguments as ineffective and repeated.
Prisca Thévenot
Thévenot said student demands should be distinguished from acts of violence and cited proposals to strengthen police resources and protect public buildings.
Saporta and Thévenot debated social unrest, protests and Emmanuel Macron’s record on LCI.
Thévenot defended the government’s actions and urged Saporta to get involved and make proposals.
Saporta dismissed Thévenot’s arguments and said she was not interested in hearing them.
The altercation circulated on X, where reactions were divided, according to 21News.
- Participants
- Isabelle Saporta and Prisca Thévenot
- Programme
- Brunet sans filtre
- Broadcaster
- LCI
- Date
- 19 October 2026
- Topics
- Social unrest, protests and Emmanuel Macron’s record
- Location of discussion
- Television studio on LCI
3 sources
« Comment osez-vous encore ouvrir la bouche ? » : violent clash entre Isabelle Saporta et Prisca Thévenot sur LCI
« Mais comment osez-vous encore ouvrir la bouche ? » : Isabelle Saporta se déchaîne contre Prisca Thévenot sur LCI
«Comment osez-vous encore ouvrir la bouche ?» : Isabelle Saporta excédée par Prisca Thevenot sur LCI
What people are saying
Vous faites partie de cette même vague saumâtre dans laquelle nous sommes et qui a mis le pays depuis dix ans à genoux
En fait, ça ne m'intéresse pas.
Engagez-vous et venez faire des propositions
Vous ne m’écoutez pas alors que je vous parle et que je vous réponds