Politics · Australia · 7 hrs ago
NSW shelves underquoting rules as Victoria tests price transparency
NSW Premier Chris Minns shelved underquoting reforms just hours before they were due to take effect.
Underquoting is when a home is advertised below the price a seller really wants, which can mislead buyers and encourage bids they cannot afford.
In Victoria, sellers must publish their auction reserve at least a week before the auction and share details of nearby comparable sales and their prices.
The rules are intended to give buyers more information, but their effect on the market is still unclear.
Melbourne’s auction clearance rate has fallen since the changes, though Sydney’s has fallen further and rising interest rates may also be affecting sales.
Melbourne is holding fewer auctions, with more new listings choosing private sales, but it is not clear whether the reforms caused the shift.
The Real Estate Institute of Victoria has called for a review and possibly scrapping the rules, while NSW’s proposed reforms are on hold.
New South Wales shelved underquoting reforms just hours before they were due to take effect.
Premier Chris Minns said he acted after real estate agents in his electorate warned the rules would make selling more difficult.
Victoria introduced price-transparency rules last month, including requiring sellers to publish an auction reserve at least a week before the auction.
Early data has not shown whether the Victorian rules caused concerns raised by the Real Estate Institute of Victoria.
Melbourne auction activity has weakened, but Sydney’s auction clearance rate has fallen further, and the causes are unclear.
- Who
- The New South Wales government, led by Premier Chris Minns, shelved the reforms. Victoria introduced its own rules.
- What
- NSW mothballed underquoting reforms, while Victoria is testing rules that require more upfront price information.
- When
- NSW shelved its reforms on Monday, hours before they were due to take effect. Victoria’s rules came into effect last month.
- Where
- New South Wales and Victoria, Australia.
- Why
- Minns said agents told him the NSW rules would make selling more difficult. The Victorian rules aim to make advertised prices more transparent for buyers.
New South Wales real estate agents
Price-transparency reform advocates
Impact on sellers
New South Wales real estate agents
Agents in Minns’s electorate told him the NSW rules would make selling more difficult.
Price-transparency reform advocates
More information for buyers and sellers should help the market move more smoothly.
Victorian rules
New South Wales real estate agents
The Real Estate Institute of Victoria says the laws could lead to more failed auctions, higher reserves and riskier sales.
Price-transparency reform advocates
The reforms require sellers to publish auction reserves and provide information about comparable sales.
Victoria’s underquoting reforms came into effect.
The New South Wales government mothballed reforms hours before they were due to take effect.
- NSW premier
- Chris Minns
- Victoria reserve disclosure
- At least one week before the auction
- Auction share
- About two in five sales in Sydney and Melbourne are auctions
- Interest rates
- Rose to their highest level in 18 years after five rate hikes this year
- Melbourne auctions
- 52% fewer than a year earlier
What people are saying
The last auction that we went to was a little bit soul destroying, to be honest
We thought that we had a chance.
Transparency is good.
More information for buyers and sellers should make the market move a bit more smoothly.