World · Europe · 6 hrs ago

Italy's top court says jeweller acted to take justice into his own hands

Italy's top court says jeweller acted to take justice into his own hands

In Grinzane Cavour, Italy, jeweller Mario Roggero killed two robbers and wounded a third after a robbery at his shop in April 2021.

Italy's Supreme Court says Roggero followed the robbers outside and fired while they were fleeing, after the robbery had ended.

The judges described his actions as a deliberate attack, not a necessary act of defence.

They rejected the claim that he acted in self-defence, saying there was no factual basis for thinking the robbers would return to threaten people inside.

The court has upheld his final sentence of 14 years and nine months for intentional homicide.

Its ruling matters because it draws a clear line between defending people from an immediate threat and pursuing suspects after danger has passed.

Roggero has also been ordered to pay €480,000 in provisional damages, and a civil action is under way to collect the money.

2 sources

Related

What people are saying

Court of Cassation judgesItaly’s top court
a deliberate attack not justified by the need for defence
via ANSA
with a voluntary and conscious choice
via Il Fatto Quotidiano
Matteo CareglioLawyer for the family of one of the robbers killed
an example of private justice
via ANSA
LeagueItalian political party
we are and will always be by his side and that of his family
via ANSA