Politics · Brazil · 6 hrs ago
Brazilian bill to repeal parental alienation law moves to Senate
Brazil’s lower house sent a repeal bill to the Senate after rejecting a request for a full-chamber vote.
The proposal, introduced in 2022 by lawmakers Fernanda Melchionna and Sâmia Bomfim, would repeal a 2010 law on parental alienation.
The law describes this as one parent interfering in a child’s relationship with the other, and allows penalties including changes to custody.
Supporters of repeal say the law can stigmatize women and expose children to violence, while opponents argue it helps protect children’s family relationships and back changing it instead.
The law remains in force for now as the Senate considers the bill through its committees.
There is no deadline for the Senate review, and opposition to repeal may grow when new senators take office in 2027.
Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies rejected an appeal to require a full-chamber vote on a bill repealing the Parental Alienation Law.
The bill, introduced in 2022 by deputies Fernanda Melchionna and Sâmia Bomfim, will now go to the Senate.
The 2010 law defines parental alienation and allows penalties including warnings and changes to custody arrangements.
Supporters of repeal say the law can stigmatize women and expose children to violence.
Deputy Carlos Jordy argued that the law protects children and proposed amending it rather than repealing it.
- Who
- Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies and Senate, and the bill’s sponsors, deputies Fernanda Melchionna and Sâmia Bomfim.
- What
- The Chamber rejected an appeal to require a full-chamber vote on a bill to repeal the Parental Alienation Law, sending it to the Senate.
- When
- The Chamber made the decision on November 11; the bill was introduced in 2022.
- Where
- Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies; the bill moves to the Senate.
- Why
- The appeal sought to require a vote by all 513 deputies rather than a decision by committees. The bill’s sponsors seek to repeal the law.
Supporters of repealing the law
Supporters of keeping or amending the law
Effect of the law
Supporters of repealing the law
They say it can stigmatize women and expose children to situations of violence.
Supporters of keeping or amending the law
They say the law protects children from psychological manipulation and safeguards family relationships.
Legislative approach
Supporters of repealing the law
They support repealing the 2010 law.
Supporters of keeping or amending the law
Carlos Jordy supports changing the law without repealing it.
Deputies Fernanda Melchionna and Sâmia Bomfim introduced a bill to repeal the 2010 law.
The Chamber rejected an appeal seeking a full-chamber vote and sent the bill to the Senate.
The bill was to be reviewed by Senate committees, with no deadline stated.
- Law enacted
- 2010
- Bill introduced
- 2022
- Bill sponsors
- Fernanda Melchionna and Sâmia Bomfim
- Chamber decision
- November 11
- Full-chamber size cited in appeal
- 513 deputies
What people are saying
Despite the controversies that have arisen over the years because of distortions and incorrect applications, it is undeniable that this law plays an essential role in protecting children and adolescents exposed to psychological manipulation and in guaranteeing the fundamental right to balanced family life.
Real cases, such as that of singer Murilo Huff (...) show how appropriate legal instruments can safeguard a child’s right to healthy contact with their parent.