Politics · Canada · 1 day ago

Lawyers appeal cut to fees from $510M to $23M in treaty settlement

Lawyers appeal cut to fees from $510M to $23M in treaty settlement

Lawyers are asking Ontario’s Court of Appeal to restore their fees from a case that secured a $10-billion settlement for 21 Robinson Huron Treaty First Nations.

The case sought retroactive payments for access to natural resources in the First Nations’ traditional territory north and east of Lake Huron.

Under the 1874 treaty terms, annual payments were set at $4 per person, despite a promise they would rise as the value of the land’s resources grew.

The legal case took more than a decade, and the lawyers agreed to lower hourly rates in exchange for 5 per cent of any settlement.

Two First Nations challenged the team’s $510-million bill, and a judge later reduced it to $23 million.

The lawyers say the judge did not properly account for their financial risk and the unusual demands of the case; the judge’s concern was the fee’s value to the clients.

The appeal is being heard by a three-judge panel, which will decide whether the fee reduction stands.

1 source

Related

What people are saying

Brian GoverCounsel for Nahwegahbow Corbiere Genoodmagejig
This court may never hear an appeal like this one again
via CBC
The application judge began from his visceral reaction to the size of the fee and worked backward to his conclusion that the legal team should not receive it.
via CBC
Failure would not have been left in the courtroom. It would have followed them home.
via CBC