Entertainment · Film · 3 hrs ago
Home Alone Director and Daniel Roebuck Dispute How Actor Lost Marv Role
Home Alone director Chris Columbus says Daniel Roebuck was fired from the 1990 film after a screen test for the role of Marv.
Columbus said the studio would not pay for Daniel Stern, his preferred choice, so another actor was tried alongside Joe Pesci, who played Harry.
Columbus says the screen test went badly, and that he later hired Stern to play Marv.
Roebuck, who has said he was let go after four days, disputes that a screen test with Pesci took place.
He said Columbus’s comments were troubling, but also praised Stern and Pesci as the right choices for the roles.
The two accounts conflict over how Roebuck left the film, and no further step or resolution is reported.
Director Chris Columbus said the studio would not pay for Daniel Stern to play Marv in Home Alone, so another actor was tested with Joe Pesci.
Columbus said the test went badly and that he fired the unnamed actor, later identified in the articles as Daniel Roebuck.
Roebuck disputed Columbus’ account, saying there was no screen test with Pesci and that the production tried to get him to quit.
Roebuck said he respects Columbus and still hopes they can work together.
The disagreement was discussed after Columbus spoke about the casting on the Wildmen podcast.
- Who
- Home Alone director Chris Columbus and actor Daniel Roebuck.
- What
- They disagree about how Roebuck lost the role of Marv.
- When
- Columbus discussed the casting on the Wildmen podcast in 2026. Roebuck responded to Entertainment Weekly.
- Where
- The casting was for the film Home Alone. The podcast appearance was on Wildmen.
- Why
- Columbus said the studio would not pay for Daniel Stern and that a screen test with another actor went badly. Roebuck disputes that account.
Chris Columbus
Daniel Roebuck
Screen test
Chris Columbus
Columbus said he tested Roebuck with Joe Pesci and that the test went badly.
Daniel Roebuck
Roebuck said there was no screen test with Pesci.
Why Roebuck left
Chris Columbus
Columbus said he had to fire the actor after the test.
Daniel Roebuck
Roebuck said the production did everything it could to get him to quit.
Marv casting
Chris Columbus
Columbus said the studio would not pay for Stern at first, so another actor was tested.
Daniel Roebuck
Roebuck said he was never going to film as Marv.
Home Alone was released with Daniel Stern playing Marv.
Roebuck said on the What a Character! podcast that he was never going to film as Marv.
Columbus discussed the casting and firing on the Wildmen podcast.
Roebuck disputed Columbus’ account in comments to Entertainment Weekly.
- Film
- Home Alone
- Marv
- Daniel Stern played the role
- Director
- Chris Columbus
- Actor identified as the earlier Marv choice
- Daniel Roebuck
- Podcast where Columbus discussed the casting
- Wildmen
- Podcast where Roebuck discussed his earlier experience
- What a Character!
3 sources
What people are saying
we didn’t have Dan Stern because the studio wouldn’t pay for Dan Stern.
We tried this other guy. And we did a screen test and they were horrible. I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful
There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that’s impossible.
They did everything they could to get me to quit