Politics · Australia · 1 hr ago
US report warns AUKUS submarine sales could weaken its fleet for years
A US Congressional Budget Office analysis warns that selling submarines to Australia could shrink the US Navy’s fleet for years.
The plan is part of AUKUS, a security agreement between Australia, the United States and the United Kingdom.
Under its first pillar, the US has agreed to sell Australia three to five Virginia-class submarines starting in 2032.
US shipyards are producing about 1.13 of these submarines a year, below the rate needed for US needs and planned transfers.
The analysis says submarine delays and limited production could make the sales harder to deliver.
It also says Australian submarines could help in a regional conflict, but Australia would control them and would not be required to join a US conflict.
US law allows a transfer only if it would not weaken US undersea capabilities, and the US can refuse without penalty.
AUKUS has broad political support in both countries, but the transfer depends on US capacity and a future assessment of its fleet.
A Congressional Budget Office report says selling nuclear-powered submarines to Australia under AUKUS would reduce the number available to the US Navy for many years.
The report warns that US shipyards are struggling to meet the Navy’s submarine demand and that production would need to rise substantially to supply Australia.
It questions whether Australian submarines would join a US conflict with China, since Australia would control its own vessels.
The report also says Australian submarines based in the Western Pacific could help offset a loss of US capability.
Under AUKUS, the US has agreed to sell Australia between three and five in-service Virginia-class submarines, beginning in 2032.
- Who
- The Congressional Budget Office assessed the impact of AUKUS submarine sales. The US and Australian navies would be affected.
- What
- The report warns that selling submarines to Australia could reduce the number available to the US Navy for many years.
- When
- The report was released on Friday morning, according to the article. The planned transfers are to begin in 2032.
- Where
- The United States and Australia. The report also discusses possible conflict involving China in the Western Pacific.
- Why
- US submarine production is struggling to meet the Navy’s demand, and replacing submarines sold to Australia would add to production challenges.
CBO report concerns
AUKUS supporters' argument
US fleet capacity
CBO report concerns
Selling submarines to Australia would reduce the number of attack submarines available to the US Navy for many years.
AUKUS supporters' argument
Australian submarines could help offset the US Navy’s potential loss of capability.
Role in a conflict with China
CBO report concerns
Australia would control its submarines, so their participation in a particular conflict would not be guaranteed.
AUKUS supporters' argument
Australian submarines based in the Western Pacific could respond more quickly to a conflict involving China.
Australian defence minister Richard Marles said Australia would make no promises to deploy its submarines in support of a US conflict with China.
The Congressional Budget Office released its analysis of the impact of AUKUS.
The planned transfer of Virginia-class submarines to Australia is due to begin.
- Planned sale
- Between three and five in-service Virginia-class submarines
- First transfers
- 2032
- US submarine production rate
- 1.13 Virginia-class submarines a year
- Rate needed for US needs
- Two submarines a year
- Rate needed for US needs and Australian transfers
- 2.33 submarines a year
- Construction time
- An average of 10 to 11 years on current schedules
What people are saying
The US submarine industrial base is currently struggling to meet the Navy’s demand for submarines
The sale of SSNs to Australia would reduce the number of attack submarines available to the Navy for many years.
under the complete control of the Australian government of the day
living a lie