Politics · Australia · 1 hr ago
Golf course challengers ordered to pay $150,000 in legal costs
Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera must pay $150,000 towards the South Australian government's legal costs after losing a court challenge.
They had tried to stop an upgrade of the North Adelaide Golf Course in Adelaide.
The redevelopment is expected to involve cutting down 585 trees in the parklands.
The pair argued the plans breached federal conservation laws, but a judge ruled in October that she was not satisfied they were likely to significantly affect species.
The government's legal bill was estimated at $450,000 to $550,000, and the challengers had rejected an earlier $150,000 settlement offer.
Kemp Attrill has raised $132,000 for the case and said they may need $170,000 for the costs order and other expenses; no further court action was stated.
Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera have been ordered to pay $150,000 towards the South Australian government's legal costs after losing a challenge to the North Adelaide Golf Course upgrade.
Federal Court Judge Natalie Charlesworth made the costs order on Thursday.
The pair had argued the redevelopment and planned felling of 585 trees breached federal conservation laws.
In October, Justice Charlesworth ruled she was not satisfied the plans were likely to have a significant impact on species.
The litigants had rejected an earlier government settlement offer of $150,000.
- Who
- Public servant Edwin Kemp Attrill and Kaurna woman Janette Milera were ordered to pay costs to the South Australian government.
- What
- They were ordered to pay $150,000 towards the government's legal costs after their challenge to the golf course upgrade failed.
- When
- Thursday, 19 November 2026.
- Where
- The Federal Court; the case concerned the North Adelaide Golf Course in South Australia.
- Why
- They lost their legal challenge to the redevelopment, which they argued breached federal conservation laws.
The litigants
The South Australian government
Costs
The litigants
The litigants argued the case was purely in the public interest and that special circumstances should be considered.
The South Australian government
The government's lawyer rejected that argument and sought costs; she indicated she would not object to an order of $150,000.
Golf course upgrade
The litigants
The litigants sought to halt the upgrade, arguing it breached federal conservation laws.
The South Australian government
The government pursued the redevelopment; the article does not state its response to the conservation-law argument.
Justice Charlesworth ruled against the litigants, finding she was not satisfied the plans were likely to have a significant impact on species.
The litigants' barrister argued the case was purely in the public interest and asked the judge to weigh special circumstances when awarding costs.
Justice Charlesworth ordered the litigants to pay $150,000 towards the government's legal costs.
- Costs ordered
- $150,000
- Litigants
- Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera
- Project
- North Adelaide Golf Course upgrade
- Trees
- 585 estimated to be cut down
- Government legal bill
- Around $450,000 to $550,000
What people are saying
This case has always been about accountability, and we have to be accountable to our actions as well, we respect the decision of the judge
This case has been a huge case for South Australia, it has taken a personal toll on us, but we're very proud to have done it.