Business · Companies · 31 mins ago
South Korean Tax Agency Disputes Labor Ruling on Samsung Union Support
South Korea’s tax agency taxed a Samsung affiliate’s union support costs as entertainment expenses, meaning the company could not deduct them fully.
The costs included a union website and an office for contract workers.
The workers, who conduct field investigations under contracts involving the affiliate and its parent company, formed a union in 2018.
The labor commission recognized them as workers for labor-law purposes, but the tax agency said they were not employees of the affiliate.
The agency also treated support for the company’s in-house union as entertainment spending, despite the company’s argument that it was required under labor agreements.
The affiliate paid additional corporate tax after the support costs exceeded the deduction limit, and its appeal was rejected.
The dispute may have wider implications as South Korea’s Yellow Envelope Law expands the circumstances in which companies can be treated as employers of contract and subcontract workers, while tax rules refer to unions organized by employees.
South Korea’s National Tax Service treated support provided by a Samsung affiliate to two unions as entertainment expenses and imposed additional corporate tax.
The agency’s decision conflicts with the National Labor Relations Commission’s recognition of contract workers as employees for labor-law purposes.
The disputed support covered a union website and office rent for a union of on-site investigators.
The company’s tax objection was rejected, and the support costs were not recognized as deductible expenses because they exceeded the entertainment-expense limit.
Labor experts criticized the tax treatment, while the National Tax Service said labor and tax judgments are separate.
- Who
- South Korea’s National Tax Service and Samsung affiliate A are at the center of the dispute. The National Labor Relations Commission and labor experts have taken different views on the workers’ status and union support.
- What
- The tax agency treated the affiliate’s support for two unions as entertainment expenses and imposed corporate tax.
- When
- The agency made the tax assessment in 2026, according to the article. The disputed support included costs from 2021 onward.
- Where
- South Korea.
- Why
- The agency said the support did not qualify as deductible costs under tax rules. It also disputed whether the on-site investigators were the company’s employees and whether their union was organized by employees.
National Tax Service
National Labor Relations Commission and labor-law critics
Workers’ status
National Tax Service
The agency said the on-site investigators could not be treated as the affiliate’s employees for tax purposes.
National Labor Relations Commission and labor-law critics
The commission recognized them as workers under labor law, citing the company’s control over their work and contract terms.
Union support
National Tax Service
The agency treated the support as entertainment expenses and said labor-law and tax judgments are separate.
National Labor Relations Commission and labor-law critics
Labor-law critics said support allowed under labor law should not be treated as entertainment, and a labor ministry official said a confirmed labor commission decision should be respected.
The on-site investigators formed a union, and the in-house union was approved as an entity treated as a corporation for tax purposes.
Samsung affiliate A began providing a 10-pyeong office to the investigators’ union under a National Labor Relations Commission settlement.
The affiliate spent 160 million won to build a website for its in-house union.
The office support for the investigators’ union was included in a collective agreement.
The National Tax Service treated the support for both unions as entertainment expenses and imposed corporate tax; the company’s objection was rejected.
- Company
- Samsung affiliate A
- Website cost
- 160 million won in 2021
- Office size
- 10 pyeong for the on-site investigators’ union
- Tax treatment
- Union support classified as entertainment expenses
- Objection
- The company’s request for a pre-assessment review was rejected
What people are saying
Treating this as entertainment is hard to understand
The National Labor Relations Commission’s decision is a different concept from tax judgment
If the labor commission’s decision has been confirmed, it would be desirable to respect it
Isn’t the National Tax Service an institution that makes that kind of judgment, and doesn’t it lack the authority?